Hip and Knee Dislocations in Extreme Sports : A Six Year National Epidemiologic Study

Vani Sabesan1*, Daniel J Lombardo1, Vinay Sharma2 and Tom Valikodath3 1Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Wayne State University School of Medicine, MI, USA 2Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Western Michigan University Homer Stryker MD School of Medicine, Kalamazoo, MI, USA 3Michigan State University College of Human Medicine, Grand Rapids, MI, USA Journal of Exercise, Sports & Orthopedics Open Access Research Article


Introduction
Extreme sports participation has continued to increase over the last few decades, with the top 5 extreme sports boasting over 40,000,000 U.S. participants in 2010, according to industry reports [1].The majority of extreme sports are high-energy, highspeed, high-risk activities [2] that may result in injuries like hip or knee dislocations that are a rare occurrence in the overall US I trauma centers with the remainder being evenly split among Levels II, III, and IV centers.These distributions demonstrate the wide representation of different hospitals inherent to this database.Patient information is collected from each NEISS hospital for every emergency visit involving an injury associated with consumer products, (i.e.sporting equipment).The clinician generated emergency department records of all injuries at each participating hospital are carefully evaluated by a hospital determined NEISS coordinator, and codes are assigned specific to the NEISS regarding product involved, diagnosis and body part affected.The database is updated daily and missing information if collected via phone interviews.Patient information including age, gender, race, location of incident, and disposition of care is also recorded for each case in the sample.There also is a free text narrative description of select cases included in this database.Each case in the NEISS sample includes a weighting value based on total annual visits at the particular emergency department from which the case was observed.These values allow for weighted estimates of injuries treated in emergency departments nationwide annually.The sampling procedure and the statistical basis for calculation of national estimates based upon the NEISS data is a validated, well described approach.
Information from the NEISS database was collected in oneyear intervals from January 1, 2007 to December 31, 2012.NEISS specific codes for a diagnosis of "dislocation" (55) and body region were used (lower trunk: 79, knee: 35) for each of the seven sports.The narrative descriptions of 308 cases were screened individually to exclude patellar dislocations.Twentytwo cases were specifically excluded for being described as patellar dislocations, therefore resulting in 286 cases of true knee dislocations.We believe that the narrative description of the remaining cases was specific enough to effectively rule out patella dislocations.The sampling weights, which are assigned to each injury case through the NEISS, were summed to provide national estimates for the different injuries.
Participation figures for the seven extreme sports were collected from annual outdoor recreation participation reports released by The Outdoor Foundation.This organization conducts an annual survey of over 30,000 individuals throughout the United States in order to quantify participation in various sports.Similar to the NEISS, they utilize a validated weighting technique to balance the data in order to reflect participation in the entire US population [13].The participation numbers acquired from the Outdoor Foundation were used to estimate incidence rates for an extreme sport population.
Incidence rates were calculated as the number of estimated hip and knee dislocations using the NEISS weighted estimates divided by extreme sports population reported by the Outdoor Foundation Report.Data was not publically available to calculate incidence rates for gender and age.Incidence rate ratios were used to compare the rates for the sports using the sport with the lowest incidence as a reference.

Results
There was a weighted estimate of 9,369.3knee dislocations and a weighted estimate of 742.02 hip dislocations over this 6 year time period.Men accounted for 60.26% of all injures and women for 39.74% of all injuries.The majority of dislocations occurred in the 10-19 year old age group, after which the number of injuries decreased with age.Regression analysis of total injuries per year showed that the injuries did increase over the time period (Figure 1) (R = 0.71).
Knee and hip dislocations for individual sports are summarized in Tables 1 and 2. Participation rates from The Outdoor Foundation are summarized in Table 3. Snow skiing had the highest estimated number of both knee and hip dislocations (Tables 1,2).
The incidence rate of knee dislocations for all seven sports over this time period was 29.12 per 1 million person-year and 2.09 per 1 million person-years for hip dislocations (Tables 1,2).

Hip and Knee Dislocations in Extreme Sports: A Six Year National Epidemiologic Study
Copyright: © 2015 Sabesan et al.
The highest incidence rate of knee dislocations in participants of extreme sports occurred in snow skiing (Table 1).The highest incidence rate of hip dislocations in participants of extreme sports occurred in snowboarding (Table 2).
Participants of winter extreme sports had a higher average incidence rate for both hip and knee dislocations.Participants in winter extreme sports had a knee dislocation incidence rate of 36.89 per 1 million person-year dislocations per 1 million patient-years, compared to 21.79 for participants of the summer sports (IRR = 1.69).Likewise, winter extreme sports participants had an average incidence rate of 2.37 per 1 million person-year hip dislocations compared to 1.67 for summer sports participants (IRR = 1.42).
Hip and knee dislocations were more common among males than females in the eight studied sports, with males accounted for 60.26% of all dislocations.Despite the overall preponderance of male knee dislocations, female knee dislocations outnumbered males in snow skiing, roller-skating, and snowmobiling (Table 3).
The occurrence of lower joint dislocations varied for different age groups.The highest occurrence of hip and knee dislocations in extreme sports was in the ten to nineteen years old group (38.7% of all injuries).The 20-29 year old group had the second highest proportion of injuries (23.2%).Other than the 0-9 year old age group with had relatively few injuries (0.50%), the amount of injuries decreased with age (Figure 2).

Discussion
Hip and knee dislocations are high energy and high impact injuries that can be devastating to participants at any level.Knee dislocations are limb threatening injuries because of the association with vascular injuries, which is thought to occur in 10-40% of all knee dislocations and is often associated with poor outcomes and high rates of amputation [14].Knee dislocation by definition involves damage to multiple ligaments of the knee, resulting in joint instability, limitation in return to sports and long term disability [15][16][17].Hip dislocations are another orthopedic emergency, and require early reduction to prevent avascular necrosis of the humeral head which can cause pain, surgical interventions and long term disability [4,18,19].These injuries are most often seen in motor vehicle collisions and are typically associated with other injuries, such as acetabular and pelvis fractures [20].With many of these extreme sports occurring in remote areas, it is easy to imagine how such injuries requiring emergent treatment could be associated with poor outcomes.The purpose of this study was to provide previously unknown data and establish demographic and incidence rates of hip and knee dislocations for extreme sports participants in the US using the NEISS database.
Overall, extreme sport participants are more likely to dislocate their knee than their hip.Snow skiing had the greatest incidence rate of knee dislocations and snowboarding had the highest incidence rate of hip dislocations among extreme sports participants.The majority of injuries occurred in the 10-19 year old age group.While this may be related to higher participation rates in this age group, it is clear that age is also a risk factor for these types of injuries.These findings highlight the areas in greatest need of improved protection due to their increased risk.
Overall there was a higher rate of hip and knee dislocations in males compared to females.For the majority of sports examined males had a greater numbers of knee dislocations except in snow skiing, roller-skating, and snowmobiling.These findings may provide insight to emphasize better gender specific safety equipment and programs for male participants in extreme sports.A limitation of this conclusion is that the higher number of injuries may be associated with higher participation rates among men.

Hip and Knee Dislocations in Extreme Sports: A Six Year National Epidemiologic Study
Copyright: © 2015 Sabesan et al.
The limitations of this study involve those inherent to the NEISS and Outdoor Foundation database reporting.This includes injuries being inaccurately or incorrectly entered due to poor use or interpretation of the specific codes.Additionally, due to how the NEISS codes certain sports, injury estimates may include more than just injuries due to that sport, resulting in inflation of the number of reported injuries.In addition, potential misclassifications of less serious injuries for dislocations may have occurred in the database that could our results.

Conclusion
This study highlights the incidence rates of hip and knee dislocations in participants of seven popular extreme sports using the NEISS database.The remote areas in which many extreme sports occur and the need for immediate treatment of many of these injuries present a unique problem.Even more, these injuries can potentially have severe complications resulting in impaired function and decreased quality of life.It is important that this problem be recognized and that those involved in extreme sports adhere to regulations and use of recommended protective equipment to better insure the safety of these athletes.We believe that this database can be continually used to monitor the rates of these injuries among extreme sports participants to reassess and future changes or improvements in injury prevention.

Figure 1 :
Figure 1: Weighted estimates of hip and knee dislocations in extreme sports by year.

Figure 2 :
Figure 2: Weighted estimates of hip and knee dislocations in extreme sports by age groups.

Table 2 :
Hip dislocation, national weighted estimates of injuries, and incidence rates from 2007-2012.Incidences are in 1 million patientyears.There were no reported hip dislocations for surfing or rollerskating.IRR= Incidence Rate Ratio, based on lowest incidence sport.

Table 3 :
Weighted estimates of knee dislocations in extreme sports from 2007-2012 by gender.