Research Article
Open Access
Dysmenorrhea in School Area in Benin
Tshabu Aguemon C*, Yunga F. J-D, Hounkponou F, Kpokoun E , Takpara I, Adisso S
Health science faculty of Abomey Calavi University, Benin
*Corresponding author: Tshabu Aguemon Christiane, Health science faculty of Abomey Calavi University, BP 1878, Benin; E-mail:
@,
Received: December 14, 2015; Accepted: June 29, 2015; Published: July 15, 2015
Introduction: Described since antiquity and long been considered
as an Epiphenomenon Dysmenorrhea benefit since some years from a
renewal of interest. The aim was to determine the prevalence and the
social impact of Dysmenorrhea in school area.
Method and patients: It was a prospective, analytical and
descriptive study, basing on a sample of 512 students in Cotonou
during a period of 4 months (from March to June 2014).
Results: The global prevalence of Dysmenorrhea in school
environment was high in 65.6%. The majority of investigated students
(58.6%) is between 16 and 20 years old and is for the most part
bachelors (96.6%). The essential Dysmenorrhea represented 49.1%.
Premenstrual dysmenorrhea represented 51.5% followed by protomenial
dysmenorrhea 36.5% then tele-menial dysmenorrhea 10.9%.
The family backgrounds of dysmenorrhea was found in 37.3% (p =
0.001). The dysmenorrhea was responsible of school absenteeism
in 32.1% of cases. The statistical analysis had made that, there is a
relation between the age and the dysmenorrhea (p = 0.021, OR=1.83
[1.04; 3.20]); the proportion of painful menses women is more
important at the less than 20 years (67.4%) than in the row of more
than 20 years (32.6%).
Conclusion: Dysmenorrhea in the teenager is becoming more and
more frequent during gynecological consultation in our department.
It affects more than one teenager over three during our survey.
Keywords: Female pupils; Dysmenorrhea; Psycho-social
influence
Introduction
Dysmenorrhea is a real public health problem. It was
described since antiquity, and has been considered for a long time
as an epiphenomenon. Dysmenorrhea knows since few years
a regain of interest. Recent study indeed underlined the role of
a uterine hyper contractibility associated with dysregulation
of the synthesis of some uterine prostaglandins. It resulted a
more coherent physio-pathological conception, and thereby, a
better adapted therapeutic management [1,2,3]. According to
Dawood, 50% of women complain of simple pain and 10% of the
invalidating form. Nevertheless 79% of teenagers are attained
by dysmenorrhea and 18% of them have the invalidating form
according to Robinson [3, 4]. Dysmenorrhea had a considerable
importance in socio-professional life of girls by conditioning
their immobilization, their scholar absence, their sportive
and intellectual counter performance, their sick stop. At this important socio-professional dimension, is added the psychosocial
impact and their repercussion in the psychism [5].
The aims were to identify the different factors susceptible to
influence Dysmenorrhea in school environment and to study the
psycho-social impact on the quality of the pupil's life.
Patients and Methods
The study was proceeded in four secondary school in Benin.
Two public and two private: general teaching public college
"Nokoué", general teaching public college "Pylônes", private
teaching college "Marthin Luther King" and private college
"Vatican". It was about a transversal, descriptive and analytical
study, over a 4 months (March to June2014).The female pupils
regularly registered in these 4 schools, having already menses
and having freely agreed were included in the study. The sample
size was determined by the formula of Schwartz(x = 1.96, p = 0.79,
i = 5%). In accordance with the formula of Gauss, we multiply
manpower by 2 (N= 509.85). The size of our sample was rounded
to 512 pupils. We proceeded by simple random sampling: the first
pulling of six districts of Cotonou of the thirteen, then the second
pulling of three districts out of six. Then we indexed the public
and the private schools in the three selected districts. We chose
two privates and two publics by lot. Thus according to the size
of our sample, we chose 128 girls randomly per school. As soon
as one entered the school yard during the recreation, the first
128 girls met according to our criteria were selected. A specimen
of enlightened assent was presented after a short explanation
before the handing-over of the questionnaire. To respect the
confidentiality, a ballot box was laid out in the secretariat of each
school to slip there the filled out cards which we recovered at
the end of each week. The entry and the data analysis were done
by SPSS 21 software. The proportions were used to describe the
qualitative variables. The average, and the standard deviation
in one side or the median and the interquartile interval in the
other side, were used to describe the quantitative variables. As for the comparison of the proportions, when the conditions are
present, we use the CHI2 test of Pearson, the corrected test of
Chi test of Yates and test of Fischer. When there is a link between
2 variables we used Odds Ratio. We chose to work with a risk of
error of 5%. If the degree of significativity is p < 0.05, there is a
significant relation.
Results
We recorded 512 pupils; only 65.5% of them were suffering
Table 1: Division by type of triggering factors.
Triggering factors |
Effective |
Percentage (%) |
High Genital infection |
14 |
4.16 |
First Sex relation |
11 |
3.27 |
Spontaneous abortion |
4 |
1.19 |
Delivery |
2 |
0.59 |
Induced abortion |
1 |
0.3 |
Infection |
1 |
0.3 |
Spontaneous |
303 |
90.17 |
Total |
336 |
100.0 |
of Dysmenorrhea. The age means was 17 years with extreme
of 10 and 25 years. The dominant age range was 16 to 20
years (62.2%). The majority of the student are single (96.6%)
and were Beninese. The pupils which had their first menses
between 13 and 15 years represented 65.8%. The age means
of the beginning of menses was 13 to 17 years (Min=9 Max=19
standard deviation= 1.7). The majority of the pupils had irregular
cycle (61.1%), primary dysmenorrhea 49.1% and secondary
dysmenorrhea 50.9%. In 4.16%, dysmenorrhea started after an
upper genital infection Table 1. Premenstrual dysmenorrhea
represented 51.5% followed by proto-menial dysmenorrhea
36.5% then tele-menial dysmenorrhea 10.9%. The average
duration of the pains was 2.9 days (min=1, max=6, standard
deviation 1.4, median, 3.0). According to the scale of Sultan, the
severe and moderated dysmenorrhea was found respectively
in 40.1 % and 44.1%. More than half of the pupils are suffering
from Dysmenorrhea (50.5%) announced asthenia like signs
accompaniment Table 2. More of the third of the dysmenorrhea
pupils 45.8% announced that the pain menses increased with the
years and 32.8% announced that the pain menses did not vary.
The family antecedent of dysmenorrhea was found in 56.8%. The
majority of dysmenorrhea pupils 97.3%, did not have a surgical
antecedent. The statistical analysis had made that, there is a
relation between the age and the dysmenorrhea (p= 0.021, OR
= 1.83 [1.04; 3.20]); the proportion of painful menses women is
more important at the less than 20 years (67.4%) than in the row
of more than 20 years (32.6%). A link is between dysmenorrhea
and matrimonial situation (p= 0.002 OR = 1.70 [0.90; 3.23]) the
single pupils 60.5% makes more dysmenorrhea than the others.
There is no link between the dysmenorrhea and the age of the
first menses (p = 0.201). There is no link between the duration of the cycle and the painful menses (p = 0.026, OR = 1.52 [1.03;
2.25]). There is no link between the use of contraceptive method
and dysmenorrhea (p = 0.085, OR = 1.7 [0.93; 2.33]). There is no
link between the upper genital infections and the dysmenorrhea
(p = 0.474, OR = 1.7 [0.75; 1.84]). There is a link between the
family antecedent of dysmenorrhea (37.3%) and coming up of
painful menses to the pupil (p = 0.001, OR = 2.25 [1.52; 3.33]
Table 3. The school absence the first day of the menses was noted
at 32.1%; there is a link between the intensity of the pain and the
absence in class (p = 0.001). The premenstrual moral state for the
majority of dysmenorrheic appeared by nervousness (42.9%)
with the approach of menses, by unhappiness (33.9%) and the others are indifferent. The majority from painful menses patients
58.3% declared that the pain did not obstruct at all their social
life; on the other hand for 8%, dysmenorrhea had an enormous
impact on their social life. 38.7% of painful menses pupils thought
that the dysmenorrhea was normal and 44.0% thought that the
pain was a momentary state Table 4.
Discussion
The frequency of dysmenorrhea is variable in the literature.
Wildhom [6] in Norway, over 5000 female school pupils
interrogated, 13% had constantly painful menses, and 38% had
it occasionally either a global frequency of 51% of dysmenorrhea.
According to Klein [7], the frequency of dysmenorrhea increases
with age (39% at the age of 12 years and 72% at the age of 17);
it increases no matter the age when gynecological life passes 2
years. The age means in our survey was 14.37 years. The strongest
rate of dysmenorrhea was found in the 15 years old patients. We
observed a progressive increase of dysmenorrhea frequency
as from the age of 16 years. The majority of the teenagers
were nulligestes (84.6%) and the nulliparous ones (93%).The
nervous mechanisms of the dysmenorrhea make it possible to
explain this phenomenon. Indeed there is a regression even the
disappearance of the menstrual pains after a pregnancy carried
out in long in term. It makes think that the uterine innervation is
completely altered and deteriorated by pregnancy [8]. It is not
the simple fact of the state of pregnancy since dysmenorrhea does
not disappear after a miscarriage or a voluntary interruption of
pregnancy in the first term. This phenomenon is not constant
since NG [9] finds 60% of dysmenorrhea after the first childbirth.
We observed 7% of dysmenorrhea after the first childbirth.
The pelvic surgery with effraction in uterine cavity exposes
to uterine synechia responsible of secondary dysmenorrhea.
In our survey, 2 painful menses patients had an antecedent of
caesarian and one painful menses patient had the antecedent of
myomectomy. Out of our survey, 60.8% had their first menses
after the age of 13 years and 24.8% before the age of 13 years.
Andersch [3] finds that dysmenorrhea is higher if the first
menses occurs earlier. We found 53.2% of genital and urinary
infection antecedent. Dysmenorrhea can occur in certain cases at
the ending of a pelvic infection syndrome. Although coelioscopy
does not always objectify visible adherences or lesions, the responsibility for the infectious process old sometimes, is to be
retained [10]. The intensity of the pain appreciated at the scale
Table 2: Division of dysmenorrhea by type of malaise.
Type |
Effective |
Percentage (%) |
Wickness |
107 |
50.5 |
Loss of appetite |
77 |
36.3 |
Bad feeling |
36 |
17.0 |
Hungry |
35 |
16.5 |
Head ache |
32 |
15.1 |
Vomissement |
31 |
14.6 |
Nausea |
24 |
11.8 |
Lots of knowledge |
5 |
02.3 |
Table 3: Factors can influenced the dysmenorrhea.
|
Effective |
Effective Percentage % |
Not Effective |
Not Effective Percentage % |
|
IMC (18-25)
|
294 |
57.4 |
143 |
27.9 |
P=0.078 |
Age (16-20 ans)
|
209 |
40 .8 |
91 |
17.7 |
P=0.021 |
Single |
310 |
60.5 |
154 |
30.0 |
P=0.002 |
Menarche (13-15 ans) |
214 |
41.7 |
123 |
24.0 |
P=0.201 |
Cycle irregular
|
219 |
42.7 |
97 |
18.9 |
P=0.026 |
Flow of menstruation more than two days
|
260
|
50.7 |
124 |
24.2 |
P=0.144 |
Use of familly planning
|
244 |
47.6 |
140 |
27.3 |
P=0.085 |
More than two girl in the fratry
|
271 |
52.9 |
143 |
27.9 |
P=0.871 |
No sexual disease transmission |
250 |
48.8 |
136 |
26.5 |
P=0.474 |
No chirurgical antecedent
|
244 |
47.6 |
140 |
27.3 |
P=0.085 |
Good relationship with parents
|
115 |
22.4 |
70 |
13.6 |
P=0.646 |
Antecedent familial of dysmenorrhea
|
191 |
37.3 |
65 |
12.6 |
P=0.001 |
of Sultan (EVS) had shown 37.9% of moderated pain during the
menses and 6.1% had a very intense pain. The other cases are of
33.6% for the weak pains and 22.4% for the intense pains. With
the score of numeric scale 65.3% had a clinical score ranging
between 4 and 7 (moderate pain) and 16.4% of the patients with
a clinical score ranging between 8 and 10 (unbearable pain). We
note that results got on simplified verbal scale (E.V.S) and on
numeric scale are very different. There might be either an over
estimation of the pain intensity either a difficulty in patients to
understand the principle of evaluating the pains that they felt.
The socio-economic repercussion of the dysmenorrhea was
evaluated by the absentee rate. In our series we found 37.4% of
absenteeism. CH. Sultan [11] finds 35% of absenteeism related
to the dysmenorrhea. Klein and Litt [7] reported a rate of 25%
while Andersch and Milsom [3] found 15.4% of absenteism. It is
indeed a social phenomenon with a considerable socio-economic
repercussion since dysmenorrhea is responsible for 600 million
hours lost a year in the United States, representing two million
dollars and 30 million hours lost in France [12,13,7,14,15,6].
The use of clinical score enabled us to obtain 68.7% from light
dysmenorrhea, 27.1% of moderate dysmenorrhea and 4.2%
of severe dysmenorrhea. Klein and Litt [7] in their study in
the United States found 49% from light dysmenorrhea, 37% of
moderate dysmenorrhea and 14% of severe dysmenorrhea. A
psychological problem of order was found at 41.1% of the painful
menses teenagers during our study. The psychological factors
were evoked from time immemorial in so far as the pain will
be an element of attraction or attention of the other people on
oneself. The cyclic character of the pain becomes a "recall then".
In our study, 71.2% (n=163) had a primary dysmenorrhea and 23.8% (n=51) a secondary dysmenorrhea. It is known as that the
primary dysmenorrhea is the prerogative of the young teenager
before 20 years, and the secondary dysmenorrhea occurs rather
after 20 years [10].
Statistical analysis
Type of dysmenorrhea in function of Age
We observed that primary dysmenorrhea occurred mainly
between the age of 13 years and 16 years. On the other hand,
the secondary dysmenorrhea is more frequently observed
at more advanced age in particular between 17 years and
19 years [Khi2 = 28.85, p = 0.0000001]. This difference is
statistically significant. These results can be explained by the
immaturity of the hypothalamo-hypophyso-ovarian axis creating
a hormonal imbalance in the case as of primary dysmenorrhea
and the exposure to etiologic factors in the case of secondary
dysmenorrhea.
Type of Dysmenorrhea in function of Menarche Age
Primary dysmenorrhea is more frequent when the first
menses occurs after the age of 13 years [Khi2 = 27.17, p =
0.0000009]. This difference is statistically significant. The survey
of Andersch [3], emphasiezed that dysmenorrhea is frequency
higher if the first menses occurs earlier.
Severity of Dysmenorrhea in function of Psychological
Factors
Psychological factors affect the severity of dysmenorrhea
Table 4: Division of dysmenorrhea by the thinking about it.
Types |
Effective |
Percentage (%) |
Normal |
130 |
38.7 |
Will passed |
148 |
44.0 |
For all the live |
10 |
03.0 |
disease |
33 |
09.8 |
Indifferent |
15 |
04.5 |
Total |
336 |
100.0 |
This marked influence is noted in the moderate and sever
dysmenorrhea [Khi2 = 58.78, p = 0.000000]. This difference
is statistically significant. According to Sultan CH [11],
psychological factors play a central role. They were mentioned
every time: refusal of femininity, desire to draw the attention
of the entourage, absenteism. We noticed that dysmenorrhea
occurs willingly to unique girls raised up by unique mothers
(widowed or divorced) or when the phratry is only made of boys.
When scholar performance is low, dysmenorrhea is a pretext to
miss class.
Type of Dysmenorrhea in function of socio-economic
state of parents
We noticed that primary dysmenorrhea occurs frequently
in high socio-economic category. One can see there a great
availability of parents to listen to and take care of the pains of
their teenagers. On the second hand, secondary dysmenorrhea is
observed with a higher frequency in low socio-economic category.
It can be explained by a great risk exposure to various supporting
factors. This difference is significant [Khi2 = 7.73, p =0.0054416].
Klein [7] had found a correlation between the dysmenorrhea
and the socio-economic statute. It is more frequent in high socioeconomic
category.
Conclusion
Dysmenorrhea in the teenager is becoming more and more
frequent during gynecological consultation in our department.
It affects more than one teenager over three during our survey.
Psychological factors must be taken into account in the moderate
and sever dysmenorrhea. Primary dysmenorrhea is the most
frequent and as for the secondary one, it develops on a lesion
context.
- Abel Mh, Baird DT. The effect of 17β estradiol and progesterone on prostaglandin production by human endométrium maintained in organ culture. Endocrinology. 1980;106(5):1599-1606.
- Alvin PE, Litt IF. Current status of the étiology and management of dysmenorrhea in adolescence. Pediatrics. 1982;70(4):516-525.
- Andersch B, Milson I. An epidemiological study of young women with dysmenorrhea. Am J Obstet Gynaecolo. 1982;144(6):655-660.
- Akerlund M. Pathophysiology of dysmenorrhea. Acta Obstet Gynecol scand. 1979;87(suppl):27-32.
- Bersjot P. Socio-economic implications of dysmenorrhea. Acta Obstetric Gynaecology scand. 1979;58(87):67-68.
- Widholm O. Dysmenorrhea during adolescence. Acta Obstetrica et Gynecology scand 1979;58(87):61-66.
- Klein JR, Litt IF. Epidemiology of adolescent dysmenorrhea. Pediatric. 1981;68(5):661-664.
- Sjöberg No. Dysmenorrhea and uterine neurotransmetters. Acta Obstet Gynecol scand. 1979;58(87):57-59.
- Ng Tp, Tan Nc, Wansaicheong Gk. A prevalence study of dysmenorrhea in female resident aged 15-54 years in Clementi town, Singapore. Ann Acad Med. 1992;21(3):323-327.
- Fignon A., Pagneux JM, Perrotin F., Marret H., Akpadza K. et Body G. Dysmenorrhea. Encyclopedy Medico- Chirurgical (Elsevier, Paris), Gynecology, 161-A-10,1795,7p.
- Sultan Ch. – Teenager dysménorrhea. Clinical, biological and therapeutique results. Revue Fr Gynecol Obstet 1986 ; 815 :253-256.
- Dawood MY. Dysmenorrhea. Clin obstet gynecol 1990;33(1):168-178.
- Drapier E., Mikaelian S. Traitement of dysmenorrhea. Revue Fr Gynecol Obstet 1981 ; 76 :67-72.
- Polaneszky MM, Slap GB. Menstrual disorder in the teenage: dysmenorrhea and dysfunctional uterine bleeding. Pediatr Rev. 1992;13(3):83-87.
- Svanberg L, Ulmsten U.The incidence of primary dysmenorrhea in teenagers. Arch gynecol. 1981;230(3):173-177.