Case Report
Open Access
Acute Liver Failure In Pregnancy
Thomas Byrne*
Harlem hospital, 507 Lenox new York, new York 10037.
*Corresponding author: Thomas Byrne, Harlem hospital, 507 Lenox new York, new York 10037, E-mail:
@
Received:October 08 2016; Accepted: October 22 2016; Published: December 10 2016
Citation: Tyurenkov IN, Popova TA, Perfilova VN, Zhakupova O GA, Ostrovsky V, et al. (2016) Effect of RSPU-189 Compound and
Sulodexide on Placental Mitochondrial Respiration in Female Rats with Experimental Preeclampsia. SOJ Gynecol Obstet Womens
Health 2(2): 7 DOI:
http://dx.doi.org/10.15226/2381-2915/2/2/00116
Acute liver disease presenting as jaundice is a common event
occurring in pregnancy occurring in about 1 per 1000 deliveries.
The most common cause of jaundice in pregnancy is viral hepatitis.
In the developed world viral hepatitis causes about 2/3 s of cases of
jaundice in several series. [1] The great majority of viral hepatitidies
are of slow onset and course. They are rarely associated with
fulminant liver failure. This is an article about fulminant liver failure
in pregnancy. This is extremely rare in Western medicine and there
are few references, this is an attempt to develop guidelines to guide
diagnosis and treatment.
Clinical Case
This is a collage of several patients and does not exactly
represent any particular person or event.
Case One
A 31 year G4 P3003 presents at 38 weeks with a 3-day history
of icterus noticed by her husband but denied by the patient.
She also presents with bulbar muscle dysfunction for 12 hours
which she has had in the past. She has no other complaints
except a decreased appetite for one day. Her pregnancy has
been carefully followed because of a history of myasthenia gravis
which has been intensively treated in the past and previous
auto-immune thyroiditis neither presently active or requiring
treatment for a year and a history of moderate to severe asthma
which worsened during pregnancy for which she is taking
moderate dose inhaled steroids twice a day, singulair once a
day and a rescue inhaler required once a week or less. A recent
asthma exacerbation required oral steroids 6 weeks before. She
has a normally growing fetus with her most recent ultrasound
a week ago and has no history of prenatal problems and three
normal vaginal births. She has no history of surgical or medical
problems but refused thymectomy for her myasthenia and had
a recent diagnosis of cholelithiasis found incidentally during a
pregnancy ultrasound. She has no history of alcohol, substance,
or acetaminophen usage. She has not used any unusual herbs or
home remedies. She presents with normal vital signs except for
a pulse of 110. She has moderate icterus but no skin jaundice.
HEENT exam is normal as are chest and heart exams. Her
abdominal exam shows active bowel sounds, no liver tenderness,
a soft not-tender uterus with fundal height of 37 centimeters and an unengaged vertex presentation. Her extremities are normal
and move normally. Her cervix is 1 cm dilated soft -2 station with
intact membranes. There is no bruising or bleeding from her IV
site, gums, or vagina. The FHR, fetal heart rate tracing, is normal.
Routine labs for pregnancy and jaundice have been ordered. The
bulbar palsy is a sign of worsening myasthenia, neurology is
consulted. The neurologist finds minimal but generalized muscle
weakness except for bulbar muscles which are moderately weak
and recommends resumption of her previous oral corticosteroid.
She receives IV corticosteroids because of two corticosteroid
treatment courses in the last 6 months The patient’s laboratory
workup has returned with the WBC is of 13,000 with slight
eosinophilia, bands of 5% and metamyelocytes of 4%, a normal
platelet size and morphology with a count of 317,000, a mild
normochromic anemia consistent with her past values and no
evidence of DIC, disseminated intravascular coagulation. Her
urinalysis is normal, AST is 2435, ALT is 1634. Total bilirubin is
8.5 (NL 0.2 to 1.0), direct bilirubin is 2.9 (NL ~ 0). Her albumin
is 2.4 grams and A/G ratio is 0.6. Glucose and electrolytes are
normal, BUN is 6, serum creatinine 0.6. Uric acid 4.3. (NL 3.5 to
7.0) Amylase and lipase are normal. Ammonia level 48 (NL 11-
32). Fibrinogen 120 mg%. PT. 60, corrected INR of 1.5. PTT is
68 both moderately high, both possibly from reduced fibrinogen
production. A urinalysis is normal with no proteinuria and a
urobilogen of 0.2. Two hours later patient develops tachycardia,
sweating and change in her mentation over a few minutes. An
EKG was normal, a finger stick for glucose was 40 mg%. 5%
dextrose infusion resolved her symptoms within a few minutes.
An ultrasound of both her fetus and her liver are performed. The
fetal ultrasound is normal with normal estimated fetal weight,
normal amniotic fluid, a reactive NST, non-stress test, and normal
Doppler of UA, umbilical artery flow, giving a modified biophysical
of 4 of 4. Her liver shows a contracted gallbladder from a meal
2 hours previously but multiple calcified gallstones. Her liver
looks normal including size, texture, and bile duct size. There is
no evidence of sub capsular hemorrhage, cirrhosis, enlargement
or common bile duct obstruction. The Doppler studies of the
liver are normal. Internal Medicine and Gastroenterology are
consulted to assist with her care. Since she is term there is no
reason to delay labor but no immediate need for an immediate
cesarean section.
"Case Two
A 22-year-old G1P0 presents at 37 weeks’ gestation with a
4-hour history of severe nausea and vomiting. She also reports
reduced fetal movements for 2 days. She has no history of
medical or surgical problems. She has had a normal prenatal
course with an ultrasound in the last week showing a normally
growing singleton fetus. Her only significant past history was an
overnight observation 3 weeks ago because of intense RUQ pain
nausea and vomiting following a very fatty meal. Her symptoms
suggested gallstones as did an AST of 112, an ALT of 240, normal
CBC and electrolytes, amylase and lipase, total bilirubin of 0.4
direct of 0.2. She was given pain relief, hydrated, and observed.
A liver ultrasound showed no gallstones or biliary obstruction
but a final reading was not available. She was discharged home
after her AST dropped to 86 and her ALT to 200 over 6 hours
and repeat labs showed no other abnormalities with no further
therapy. She was discharged on a low-fat diet. She has no history
of drug, alcohol, acetaminophen, or herb usage. Her vital signs are
normal except for a blood pressure of 140/89 (up from 100 /69
average during pregnancy) including FHR. She has no jaundice or
icterus. HEENT exam is normal as are chest and heart exams. Her
abdominal exam shows active bowel sounds, a tender but normal
size liver, a soft, non-tender uterus of 37 cms fundal height with
an engaged vertex presentation. Her extremities are normal
except for 3+ leg edema. Her cervix is 1 cm dilated, unsoftened, 0
station, with intact membranes. There is no bruising or bleeding.
Routine labs for pregnancy and liver problems are ordered.
The patient feels better after IV Phenergan. The laboratory
workup has returned. WBC is 7,800 with a normal differential, a
normal platelet size and morphology with a count of 5,000, amid
normochromic anemia consistent with mild iron deficiency and
no evidence of DIC. Her urinalysis shows 3 plus protein. AST is
202, ALT is 363 Total bilirubin is 0.4, direct 0.3. Her albumin is
2.3 with an A/G ratio of 0.7. Glucose and electrolytes are normal.
BUN is 7 and creatinine is 0.7 (they were 10 and 0.6 3 weeks ago).
Uric acid is 5.3. Amylase, lipase, and ammonia are all normal.
Fibrinogen is 350 mg% Her PT is 20 and her PTT is 12 and
her INR is 0.9. An ultrasound of both the uterus and liver were
performed. The fetal ultrasound shows a normal fetal weight,
amniotic fluid and UA Doppler waveform and a reactive NST,
giving a modified biophysical of 4 out of 4. Her liver looks normal
in size with no biliary stones or obstruction. There is no evidence
of other abnormalities. The ultrasound reading including review
of previous ultrasound shows extensive “fatty liver changes
worse than 3 weeks ago”, but normal Doppler studies of the liver.
She is admitted due to her worsening liver tests and reduced fetal
movement at term.
Diagnostic Workup Of New Onset Jaundice
The initial diagnosis panel for jaundice includes just a
few tests. An automated CBC, with microscopic inspection if
required, a liver profile including the enzymes AST, aspartate
aminotransferase, and ALT, alanine aminotransferase, both
direct and indirect bilirubin, glucose and ammonia, a PT1,
prothrombin time, PTT, partial thromboplastin time, fibrinogen
and albumin levels, a BUN, blood urea nitrogen, serum creatinine, acetaminophen level and a urinalysis. From these tests and a
set of vitals a physical exam and history we will be able to start
the process of determining the severity of a patient’s medical
condition, get a start on determining the need for transport and
start to identify or at least rule out some of the causes of acute
liver failure in a pregnant patient. The other important but easily
determined factor is the estimated gestational age either from her
prenatal record, her history or a new ultrasound or all three. The
immediate health of the neonate at present is determined from
its electronic fetal heart surveillance and biophysical profile.
Further tests that need to be drawn are antibody and antigen
titers for the common platitudes but these will be ordered by
your consulting internist or gastroenterologist.
Defining Liver Failure
I would define liver failure as the inability of the liver to
perform its immediate important functions. The most acute
of these are maintenance of serum glucose in the fasting state,
continuous production of coagulants to maintain clotting activity
and removal of metabolic poisons, some of which are probably
still unknown, but the most important of which is ammonia. If the
liver is failing it is usually failing in all three of these functions.
So in a community hospital finding a patient with an elevated
ammonia, low fibrinogen and prolonged coagulation profile with
hypoglycemia is reason to consider transfer to a larger center.
The determination of potential fetal viability is important in
two aspects, first several of the acute liver failures of pregnancy
only occur after fetal viability and are much more common after
34 weeks of gestation and the finding of fetal viability means
that there has to be an immediate analysis of whether delivery
in beneficial to either or both the mother and neonate. With
HELLP syndrome and AFLP both of which almost universally
occur only near term, delivery is beneficial to both the mother
and the neonate. Whether delivery is safer for either, before or
after transport, is a unique complex decision for each individual
patient couple, practitioner, hospital and transport system.
Fulminant Liver Failure
Fulminant liver failure in pregnancy is much rarer in
pregnancy than jaundice and requires aggressive treatments to
maximize maternal and fetal outcomes as opposed to new-onset
jaundice. A patient will probably present in one of three ways;
new onset jaundice, probably scleral, new onset somnolence and
unusual mental changes or with hypertension, abdominal pain
and bleeding. In the United States by far the most common cause
of fulminant liver failure is acetaminophen poisoning.[2]
After diagnosis of fulminant liver failure, the later diagnostic
and therapeutic regimens need to be carried out in a center
capable of managing all the manifestations and treatments
required in this condition. Early transfer to a center with
maternal-fetal medicine, neonatology and gastroenterology
support and a blood bank capable of large transfusions and
specialty products required in this condition is essential. Part of
the decision on whether to transfer involves the gestational age
and the capability of your hospital to care for a neonate of your
patient’s gestational age. In some of these causes of fulminant
liver failure early delivery is beneficial for the patient and possibly the neonate. There are tests required in this condition to
quickly allow identification of those disease entities that require
expedited delivery. Some tests are to determine the severity of
the liver failure, some are to differentiate the cause of a particular
patient’s condition.
The first group is physical exam and history looking for
patient mental acuity and alertness, degree of scleral and skin
jaundice, liver and spleen size and tenderness and adenopathy.
It is also important to note the patient’s pulse, temperature and
blood pressure. These are all used in later differentiation of these
various disease processes. The history should include alcohol
intake, acetaminophen usage, history of previous jaundice, history
or family history of autoimmune diseases, immunosuppressive
diseases, preeclampsia or liver or metabolic diseases. These
should already be obtained from the jaundice workup.
The second group is laboratory tests that help place the
patient in a disease category. These are the same labs already
drawn for the workup of new onset jaundice. These are hepatic
enzymes, direct and indirect bilirubin, serum ammonia, CBC with
microscopic inspection if required, fibrinogen concentration,
serum amylase and lipase, glucose level, PT, (prothrombin time)
and PTT, (partial thromboplastin time), INR (derived by dividing
the PT by the average PT for your hospital) and finally serum
albumin. These should be available almost immediately. Tests
that are important but that will not be immediately available
include tests for all hepatic viruses and herpes simplex and their
antibodies. Anti-nuclear antigen, ANA, lupus anticoagulant, total
immune globulin and anti-liver specific antibodies.
The third group is imaging tests required to diagnose this
clinical problem. The first is uterine ultrasound and fetal heart
rate testing. Ultrasound liver imaging looking for cholecystitis,
cholelithiasis, hepatic duct dilation, Doppler studies of the
venous and arterial system of the liver and evidence of cirrhosis
or hepatic enlargement or subcapsular hemorrhage. Again these
should have already been done for the jaundice workup.
With these tests we should be able to come to a preliminary
diagnosis and from the working diagnosis a treatment plan.
This of course has to include not only maternal-fetal medicine
but internal medicine and gastroenterology but eventually
anesthesiology and neonatology. One other important point in
managing these disease entities is that serum testing should be
repeated after the first 12 hours of admission to determine the
course and rapidity (trajectory) of the patient’s liver failure.
There are two important causes of fulminant liver failure in
pregnancy that need to be ruled out early in a patient’s hospital
admission because they carry important therapeutic and
pregnancy associated risks. The two clinical entities are HELLP
syndrome and acute fatty liver of pregnancy. A short list of the
most common causes of fulminant liver failure in pregnancy
includes AFLP, acute fatty liver of pregnancy, Budd Chiari
syndrome, AFLD, alcoholic hepatitis, non-alcoholic hepatitis,
HELLP, Hemolysis elevated liver enzymes and low platelets, and
autoimmune hepatitis. There are other causes of fulminant liver
failure in Europe and North America but are rarer, have more complex testing and differentials and require a gastroenterologist
also knowledgeable in their diagnosis and treatment. This is an
article to help an Obstetrician start the process of care for an
affected pregnant patient. Definitive treatment will require not
only a knowledgeable gastroenterologist and internist for help
but the services available only in a large referral hospital, such as
a large lab with a blood bank capable of providing many units of
blood and blood products in an expeditious manner, an intensive
care unit with intensivists and a knowledgeable anesthesia
department.
Clinical Causes Of Fulminant Liver Failure In
Pregnancy
Budd-Chiari Syndrome:This syndrome which is extremely
rare involves the change in physiology that results from a
thrombotic event involving the veins draining the liver. The
presentation is a triad of abdominal pain, ascites and liver
enlargement. The disease process involves two processes. The
body adaptation to obstruction of blood flow returning through
the hepatic bed and the hepatic metabolic derangements that
result from this altered blood flow. Although rare pregnancy,
pregnancy is the second leading entity associated with Budd-
Chiari. It can present as a chronic condition but in pregnancy
appears acutely with the classic triad. [3] In the past the
diagnosis was sometimes made in pregnancy by exploratory
laparotomy. [4]We then progressed to ultrasound and liver
biopsy for diagnosis.[5] Now abdominal ultrasound is usually
definitive during the immediate presentation.[6] Of course an
MRI is also available for further definition if needed especially
in the morbidly obese where there are significant limitations for
ultrasound. There are no agreed upon management guidelines in
pregnancy specific for treatment of Budd-Chiari.[7] Whether to
use anticoagulants or to deliver immediately is not agreed upon.
Hellp Syndrome
This syndrome is caused by and unique to pregnancy. Its
diagnosis involves detection of disseminated intravascular
coagulation, elevated liver enzymes and thrombocytopenia
in a pregnant patient, in the absence of other causes.[8] Most
investigators consider HELLP to be a variant of pre-eclampsia
and most patients with HELLP have mild to severe signs of
preeclampsia and renal dysfunction.[9] The only cure for HELLP
syndrome is delivery. One of the leading institutions in the
United States believes that corticosteroids shortens the course
and intensity of HELLP syndrome after delivery.[10] Patients
usually complain of pain in the area of the liver. Hypertension,
even extremely severe hypertension, can be a leading finding
and the absence of any blood pressure elevation almost rules out
HELLP syndrome as a working diagnosis. It generally presents in
the third trimester near term but can present even in the second
trimester.[11] The pathognomonic hallmark is disseminated
intravascular coagulation and you cannot consider a HELLP
syndrome diagnosis without it.[12]
Acute Fatty Liver Of Pregnancy
This is thought to also be a condition unique to and caused
by pregnancy. It occurs almost exclusively only in the late third
trimester to post-par tum.[13] There are several world-wide individual reports of AFLP in the second trimester. [14, 15] Fever
is present with jaundice in more than 70% of cases. [16] Although
the exact cause is unknown it is thought to be related to the fetal
inheritance of a defective enzyme that catabolizes long chain
fatty acids leading to a fetal buildup and then a maternal buildup
of these same partially metabolized fatty acids from placental
fetal to maternal transfer. The enzyme is called 3-hydroxyacyl-
CoA dehydrogenase. [17] The excess long chain fatty acids
are transported in the blood to the liver absorption apparently
causes gradually increasing liver dysfunction. [18] The starting
manifestations are almost always headache and fatigue. 70%
complain of nausea and vomiting. [19] 80% complain of left
upper quadrant pain. Hepatic encephalopathy will occur late not
early in the disease process and itching and a skin rash can occur
weeks before intense symptoms begin.[20] This makes some to
believe this is an extreme cholestasis of pregnancy.
Alcoholic Fatty Liver Disease
Autoimmune hepatitis is another cause of jaundice in
pregnancy. Although the majority present with chronic slowonset
disease 40% present with acute symptoms. Even in the
acute group fulminant hepatic failure is rare. [21] The most
common presentation of alcoholic hepatitis during pregnancy
is from bleeding varices caused by the venous obstruction of
cirrhosis.[22] There are no case reports of acute liver failure in
pregnancy caused by alcohol found within the last fifteen years.
This despite the reported usage of alcohol to some degree by
15 to 20% of pregnant patients in the United States.[23] The
incidence of cirrhosis is also unknown but thought to be low due
to the endocrine effects of reduced liver failure and its effect on
fertility.
Non-Alcoholic Fatty Liver Disease
Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease, NAFLD is the liver
manifestation of the metabolic syndrome and is reported to be the
commonest liver disease in the world. [24] There is nevertheless
little known of its occurrence or symptoms in pregnancy.[25] It is
usually a mild disease associated with jaundice but not fulminant
liver failure.[26] The disease can occur in any trimester with
no known predilection for any. It usually presents with mild
jaundice and minimal liver dysfunction. It can progress fulminant
failure with jaundice, coagulopathy and coma. [27] Most reports
of severe liver failure in pregnancy from fatty liver are in the
older literature and most describe disseminated intravascular
coagulation which would not be considered part of non-alcoholic
fatty liver disease.[28] In the non-pregnant patient most people
with NAFLD do no present with symptoms. There are estimates
that as many as 20% of the United States population has NAFLD
at this time. [29] The definitive diagnosis is made only by liver
biopsy. [30]
There is very little written about this disease entity in
pregnancy. The risk of fulminant liver failure from this pathology
is higher in older more obese patients with insulin resistance.
[31]
Auto-Immune Hepatitis
Although not thought to be a common cause of acute liver
failure in pregnancy, auto-immune hepatitis is perhaps the best described in pregnancy thanks to a seminal work on it published
in 2000 of 162 females with this condition and pregnancy. [32]
They describe 35 pregnancies resulting in 31 live births including
patients that already had cirrhosis. This article found that this
form of hepatitis was usually less active during pregnancy and
more active in the three months following delivery. They did
have 4 acute liver flares in their 35 pregnancies though. It was
also interesting that 2 of their cohort of 31 pregnancies after the
second trimester developed eclampsia, a rate of 7%, easily 100
times the usual rate in pregnancy. A group at LSU did a Medline
search finding 58 pregnant women with AIH worldwide. They
reported a maternal mortality of 4% and a fetal mortality of about
33% but counting first trimester losses. All patients including
their cases responded to corticosteroids and azathioprine.
Determining An Intial Diagnosis In Acute Liver
Failure In Pregnancy
Let’s look at a table that allows a relatively rapid
differentiation into the six most important and common causes of
acute fulminant liver failure in a pregnant patient. It is important
to realize that any of these entities can present or have any kind
of lab values, so no single test is diagnostic or rules out any
particular entity. It is the overall pattern that is important and
sometimes a definitive diagnosis is not possible even with a later
liver biopsy. Arguably the only definitive diagnosis of liver failure
is acetaminophen poisoning with an elevated level of that toxin.
This is also the most treatable early with N-acetyl-cysteine so it is
important to not miss that diagnosis by not ordering that lab test.
The rest of the diagnoses are less definable.
Treatment Of Liver Failure In Pregnancy
The first decision is to decide on the viability and health of the
neonate. For pregnancies below the threshold of viability fetal
monitoring is not warranted and consideration of the fetal effects
of any required medication should not be considered. Anything
life-saving for the mother will be beneficial to the neonate to
maximize its chances of achieving viability. Pregnancies clearly in
the zone of fetal viability need to have continuous fetal monitoring
and the patient delivered, by cesarean section if necessary, to
maximize the neonatal life chances and minimize its morbidity.
To this end if deficits in the maternal coagulation system are
present they need to be corrected in an ongoing fashion to
facilitate operative delivery if it is needed in a rapid fashion. For
the cases where fetal viability is not yet a reasonable expectation
but might be shortly there will be a dilemma about the best
interests of the mother and neonate which might differ. In cases
of early viability where steroids would be clearly beneficial to the
neonate the only relative contraindication in these diseases are
with herpetic hepatitis where there is theoretical disadvantage
to the mother. Corticosteroids have actually been used in all the
other entities sometimes with proven benefit but never with
proven harm.
Using Table One
CASE ONE Let us now use Table 1 to see if a working
diagnosis is discernible in case one. The emphasis is on “working
diagnosis”. Definitive diagnosis requires liver biopsy in most
cases and that will not be performed during the pregnancy. She
Table 1: Differentiating Causes Of Liver Failure In Pregnancy
Table 1. |
HELLP |
AFLP |
Budd-Chiari |
AFLD |
non-AFLD |
Auto-immune |
Hypertension |
80.00% |
60.00% |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Somnolence |
No |
60.00% |
Rare |
10.00% |
10.00% |
30.00% |
Oliguria |
90.00% |
50.00% |
Rare |
No |
No |
No |
Proteinuria |
90.00% |
No |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Bleeding |
Frequent |
Frequent |
No |
Late |
Late |
Late |
Liver pain |
90.00% |
30.00% |
20.00% |
No |
No |
No |
Vomiting |
50.00% |
60.00% |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Hex of jaundice |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Low platelets |
Always < 100 k |
possible |
possible |
No |
No |
No |
Eosinophilia |
No |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Renal dysfunction |
90.00% |
50.00% |
Late unless fulminant |
Late |
Late |
Late |
WBC count |
Normal |
Greater than 15,000 |
Decreased to less than 500 |
Normal |
Normal |
Normal |
AST/ALT |
Up to 200 |
300 to 500 |
60-400 |
60-500 |
60-300 |
200-2000 |
Uric acid |
Elevated |
Elevated |
Normal |
Normal |
Normal |
Normal |
Fibrinogen |
Very low |
Mild drop |
Mild drop |
Mild drop |
Mild drop |
Very low |
Ammonia |
No |
Late |
Late |
Early |
Late |
Early |
Fever |
No |
50.00% |
No |
No |
No |
No |
INR prolongation |
Mod-severe |
Moderate |
Rare |
Mod-severe |
Moderate |
Mod-severe |
Hx auto-immune dx |
Possible |
No |
Possible |
No |
No |
Yes |
Low glucose |
No |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Doppler DX |
Subcapsular bleed |
Normal |
Doppler vein changes |
Cirrhosis possible |
Cirrhosis possible |
Cirrhosis possible |
Bilirubin elevation |
Mild |
Mild-mod |
Mild |
Mod-severe |
Moderate |
Mod-severe |
Jaundice |
Rare |
70.00% |
No |
Mod-severe |
Moderate |
Mod-severe |
DIC |
100.00% |
55.00% |
Rare |
No |
No |
No |
has no evidence of fever, hypertension, DIC, renal dysfunction.
Further although her INR is prolonged it is only moderately
prolonged suggesting low fibrinogen as the leading cause rather
than DIC. She has a normal platelet number and morphology
and a reasonably normal CBC. She also has no liver pain or
vomiting. Together these rule out HELLP syndrome and AFLP.
She has a normal liver arterial and venous Doppler exam which
by itself rules out Budd-Chiari syndrome. This leaves us with 3
possible entities causing her fulminant failure in the absence of
an elevated acetaminophen level. None of them are helped by
expedited delivery but no term fetus is helped by the metabolic
environment of a failing maternal liver. The three entities are
again; alcoholic fatty liver disease AFLD, non-alcoholic fatty liver
disease NAFLD and auto-immune hepatitis. So with this working
diagnosis induction of labor is started with oral misoprostol,
along with periodic glucose testing, urine output monitoring, the
blood bank is called to determine if an adequate supply of freshfrozen
plasma, FFP, in her type is available and to cross-match
the patient for 4 units of packed irradiated red blood cells, PRBCs
and to have the blood and FFP transported to the labor and
delivery suite. They are both available within half an hour. Her
bulbar palsy is intermittent and a sign of worsening myasthenia,
neurology consult is ordered. The neurologist finds minimal but generalized muscle weakness except for bulbar muscles which are
moderately weak and recommends resumption of her previous
oral corticosteroid. She receives IV corticosteroids because of
two corticosteroid treatment courses in the last 6 months. Her
bulbar palsy is intermittent and a sign of worsening myasthenia,
neurology consult is ordered. The neurologist finds minimal
but generalized muscle weakness except for bulbar muscles
which are moderately weak and recommends resumption of
her previous oral corticosteroid. She receives IV corticosteroids
because of two corticosteroid treatment courses in the last 6
months. The fetal heart rate is reactive at present and because
she is multiparous she is given oral misoprostol to induce labor
and an anesthesia consult is made and 10ml/kg of FFP is ordered
to normalize her coagulation profile in anticipation of delivery
and possible anesthetic or surgical intervention for her delivery.
Internal medicine orders a larger battery of tests including tests
for viral hepatitidies. At this point her older records are available
and they reveal that this patient has had two episodes of jaundice
with mild liver dysfunction lasting several weeks and resolving
several years ago. At that time, it was thought that auto-immune
hepatitis was ruled out although about 20% of patients with
this condition have negative results of tests that are somewhat
specific for that entity. A liver biopsy was never performed due
to patient reluctance. The patient starts a contraction pattern several hours after
her misoprostol oral dosage. She later develops a category 2
then a category 3 fetal heart rate tracing. She is given a general
anesthetic because of the clotting dysfunction and delivered by
cesarean section. Her baby is delivered with low APGAR s from
the anesthetics but normal blood gases and PH and does well in
the normal nursery. There were no bleeding issues during her
surgery. FFP and one unit of blood are given during the operation
to exactly replace losses. Her urine output decreases during
the surgery despite exact replacement of fluid losses and she is
transported to the labor and delivery intensive care unit. 1500
milliliters of lactated ringers and 500 of 5% dextrose solution
and one more unit of FFP are enough to start to restore adequate
urine output. Since she is delivered and has undergone another
stress and there is a possibility of this being another auto-immune
phenomenon, intravenous steroids are given in a dose usual for
auto-immune hepatitis and for treating fatty liver disease failure.
She is transported to the medical intensive care unit since she is
no longer pregnant. She was at first unresponsive thought to be
from poor hepatic drug metabolism. Over the next several hours
she becomes more responsive but then has lengthening episodes
of somnolence. Her ammonia level rises and her INR rises to 5 and
her ammonia level worsens, in the medical ICU it is determined
that the patient
has a hidden alcohol abuse problem which may be the
cause and/or contribute to her worsening liver failure? She is
transported the second day to a liver transplant unit and placed
on the list of patients needing a liver transplant. After a week of
worsening liver dysfunction, she is placed on the liver transplant
list and receives a liver transplant and has slowly recovered from
her liver failure over the next few months.
CASE TWO Let us again use table one for a working diagnosis.
She has no fever, but has mild hypertension, no evidence of DIC,
she has a significant worsening of her renal function in the last
3 weeks, there is no evidence of DIC and her clotting functions
are normal. She does have pain over her liver on palpation
and her most significant complaint is intense vomiting which
has improved with treatment to intense nausea. She also has
moderate elevation in her liver enzymes and her bilirubin.
Taken together these rule out HELLP syndrome, a normal liver
Doppler has ruled out Budd-Chiari. She has intense nausea,
hypertension, renal dysfunction, proteinuria, moderate liver
enzyme elevation and moderate renal dysfunction. Together
these rule out all of the remaining pathologies except AFLP, acute
fatty liver of pregnancy. She seems to have only mild disease
at present which is unusual but otherwise matches the profile
well. She was started on a dextrose drip with periodic glucose
testing, oxytocin to initiate labor, and urine output to monitor
renal function. She was also started on a magnesium sulfate drip
in case this was an unusual preeclampsia presentation. She is
typed and crossed for four units of PRBCs but not for other blood
components due to her normal fibrinogen and clotting profile.
Her blood pressure increases over the next four hours and she is
started on IV labetalol and magnesium sulfate. A repeat CBC and
liver profile were done. CBC was essentially unchanged, AST has risen to 304, ALT to 435 total bilirubin to1. 0 and direct to 0.7. A
repeat hepatic profile 2 hours later is unchanged except for total
bilirubin which has risen to 1,1 and direct to 0.8 She has started
a reasonable contraction pattern which the fetus tolerates. After
several hours there is fetal intolerance of labor and the patient is
delivered by cesarean section under spinal anesthesia. There are
no operative or anesthetic problems. She is kept on a magnesium
sulfate drip for 24 hours but has no other problems. 24 hours
after delivery her BUN and creatinine have improved AST has
dropped to 163 ALT to 291 total bilirubin 0.7 direct 0.4. Her other
labs remain normal. By 48 hours she is clinically normal and her
AST is 43 and her ALT 138 total bilirubin is 0.4 and direct is 0.2,
BUN is 6 and creatinine is 0.7 both approximately what they were
5 weeks previously.
Conclusion
These patients demonstrate how using commonly and
rapidly available tests and physical exam someone with
fulminant liver failure can be properly diagnosed and treated.
For the Obstetrician there are two important questions that
require answering. Are my hospital and I capable of treating all
the possible needs of this patient and her neonate? If the answer
to this is doubtful then transport as soon as possible to a center
capable of care is required. The second question is to rule out
or in and to treat HELLP syndrome and AFLP. In the second case
the patient undoubtedly had AFLP but presented in such a mild
manner that induction of labor rather than a cesarean section
was tried. Although eventually both of these patients required
expedited delivery the important action is to have a plan in
place for cesarean delivery even when you are trying to facilitate
vaginal delivery especially In a stable patient with a category
one fetal tracing, being prepared for a cesarean section makes
induction of labor safer. A cesarean section increases the odds of
excess bleeding and adds anesthetics from general anesthesia to
the patient’s somnolence, since neuraxial anesthetics are usually
ruled out by the coagulopathy of these two conditions.
Once HELLP and AFLP are ruled out, after viability, it is still
reasonable to expedite delivery at any time after 34 weeks’
gestation. A cesarean section here also complicates the care of the
patient after her delivery if she develops fever or has a bleeding
problem at her surgical site or uterus. In both scenarios a plan for
induction of labor necessarily also means the preparation for a
cesarean section should be in place. The table presented in this
article should help you develop a sense of how to diagnose these
various conditions. The laboratory tests and physical signs are
obtainable everywhere. It is important however that although
you should develop your own diagnosis that you involve internal
medicine, gastroenterology and anesthesia early in the patient’s
hospital course both for guidance and to inform your colleagues
of potential future problems far enough in advance to facilitate
the patient’s care.
- Devarbhavi H1,Kremers WK,Dierkhising R,Padmanabhan L. Pregnancy-associated acute liver disease and acute viral hepatitis: Differentiation, course and outcome. J. Hepatol. 2008;49(6):930-935. doi: 10.1016/j.jhep.2008.07.030.
- Larson AM,Polson J,Fontana RJ,Davern TJ,Lalani E,Hynan LS, et al. Acute liver failure study group. Acetaminophen-induced acute liver failure: results of a United States multicenter, prospective study. Hepatology 2006;42(6):1364-1372. DOI: 10.1002/hep.20948.
- Kyriakidis, A.V., Vezyrgiannis, I., Pyrgioti, M. Budd-Chiari syndrome. Ann. Gastroenterol.2004;21(4):223-228.
- M. Tiliacos, D.Tsantoulas, A.Tsoulias, E.Kokka, E.Eudaimon, S. Aphentoglou,et.al. The Budd-Chiari syndrome in pregnancy. Postgrad. Med. J.1978;54(636): 686-691.
- Fickert P,Ramschak H,Kenner L,Hoefler G,Hinterleitner TA,Petritsch W, et.al. Acute Budd-Chiari syndrome with fulminant heaptic failure in a pregnant women with factor V Leiden mutation. 1996;111(6);1670-1673.
- Rautou PE,Angermayr B,Garcia-Pagan JC,Moucari R,Peck-Radosavljevic M,Raffa S. et.al. Pregnancy in women with known and treated Budd-Chiar syndrome: maternal and fetal outcomes. J. Hepatol. 2009;51(1):47-54. doi: 10.1016/j.jhep.2009.02.028.
- Aggarwal N,Suri V,Chopra S,Sikka P,Dhiman RK,Chawla YK. Pregnancy outcome in Budd Chiari Syndrome-A tertiary care centre experience. Arch. Gynecol.Obstet. 2013;288(4):949-952. doi: 10.1007/s00404-013-2834-8.
- Haram K, Svendsen E, Abilgaard U. The HELLP syndrome: Clinical issues and management. A review. BMC Pregnancy and childbirth .2009;9(8) 1-66. DOI: 10.1186/1471-2393-9-8.
- Padden M.O. HELLP syndrome: Recognition and perinatal management. Am. Fam. Physician .1999;60(3): 829-836.
- Wallace K,Martin JN Jr,Tam Tam K,Wallukat G,Dechend R,Lamarca B. Seeking the mechanism(s) of action for corticosteroids in HELLP syndrome: SMASH study. Am.J. Ob. Gyn. 2013;208(5):380.e1-8. doi: 10.1016/j.ajog.2013.01.049.
- Kelly J, Ryan D.J, O'Brien N.O, Kirwan W.O. Second trimester hepatic rupture in a 35 year old nulliparous woman with HELLP syndrome: a case report. World J. Emer. Surg.2009;4:23. doi:10.1186/1749-7922-4-23.
- Tsokos,M. Pathological features of maternla death from HELLP syndrome.2004;1(1):275-290.
- Hin Hin Ko , Eric Yoshida. Acute ftty liver of pregnancy. Can. J. Gastroenterol.2006;20(1):25-30.
- Buytaert IM,Elewaut GP,Van Kets HE. Early occurrence of acute fatty liver in pregnancy. Am. J. Gastroenterol. 1996;91(3):603-604.
- Monga M., Katz A.R. Acute fatty liver in the second trimester. Obstet. Gynecol. 1999;93(5 PT 2):811-813.
- Simpson KR ,Luppi CJ ,O'Brien-Abel N. Acute fatty liver of pregnancy. J.Perinat. Neonatal Nurs. 1998;11(4):35-44.
- Schoeman,M.N., Baley,R.G., Wilcken,B. Recurrent acute fatty liver of pregnancy associated with afatty-acid oxidation defect in the offspring. Lancet (1991) 100: 544-546.
- Jamal A Ibdah. Acure fatty liver of pregnancy: an update on pathogenesis and clinical implications. World J. Gastroenterol. 2006;12(46):7397-7404. doi:10.3748/wjg.v12.i46.7397.
- Kaplan M.M. Acute fatty liver of pregnancy. N.Eng.J. Med. 1985;313(6):367-370. DOI: 10.1056/NEJM198508083130606.
- Reyes H ,Sandoval L,Wainstein A,Ribalta J,Donoso S,Smok G, et al. Acute fatty liver of pregnancy: a clinical study of 12 episodes in 11 patients. Gut .1994;35(1):101-106.
- Mann M.P , Czapa J.A ,Gorham J.D , Krawitt E.L , Mieli-Vergani G , Vergani D , et al. Diagnosis and management of autoimmune hepatitis. Hepatology .2010;51(6):2193-2213.
- Puljic A., Salati J., Doss A., Caughey A.B. Outcomes of pregnancy complicated by liver cirrhosis, portal hypertension, or esophageal varices. J. Mat. Fet & Neonatal Med. 2016:29(3).doi.org/10.3109/14767058.2015.1009438.
- US Dept. Health Human Services, Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, Office of Applied Studies, National Household Survey on Drug Use and Health, 1994. Rockville,Md: US Dept Health Human Services.1995
- Page,L.M. Girling,J.C. A novel cause for abnormal liver function tests in pregnancy and puerperium- non-alcoholic fatty liver disease- the first reported case series. Arch. Dis.Child Fetal Neonatal. Ed. 2010:95;59-60. doi:10.1136/adc.2010.189753.89.
- Hannes Hagström, Jonas Höijer, Jonas F. Ludvigsson, Matteo Bottai, Anders Ekbom, Rolf Hultcrantz . Adverse outcome of pregnancy in women with non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. Liver Int. 2016;36(2):268-274.doi: 10.1111/liv.12902
- Castracane.v , Davis,G, Martinez,B, Maguire,C ,Kauffman. R. Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease in pregnant women. Endo. Abtstracts. 2012;29:938.
- Ockner SA ,Brunt EM,Cohn SM,Krul ES,Hanto DW,Peters MG. Fulminant liver failure cuased by acute fatty liver of pregnancy treated by orthotopic liver transplantation. Hepatology. 1990;11(1):59-64.
- Castro,M.A., Fassett,M.J., Reynolds,T.B., Shaw,K.J., Goodwin,T.M. Reversible peripartum liver failure: a new perepsective on the diagnosis, treatment, and cause of acute fatty liver of pregnancy, based on 28 consecutive cases. Am. J. Obstet.Gynecol. 1999;181(2):389-395.
- Lazo M.,Clark JM. The epidemiology of nonalcoholic fatty liver diease: a global perspective. Semin. Liver Dis. 2008;28(4):339-350. doi: 10.1055/s-0028-1091978.
- Clark JM, Brancati FL, Diehl AM. Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease. Gastroenterol. 2002;122(6):1649-1657.
- Rinella ME. Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease. A systematic review. JAMA. 2015;313(22):2263-2273. doi: 10.1001/jama.2015.5370.
- Heneghan MA, Norris SM., O'Grady JG, Harrison PM., McFarlane I.G. Management and outcome of pregnancy in autoimmune hepatitis. Gut. 2001 48(1):97-102. doi:10.1136/gut.48.1.97.
- Candia L, Marquez J, Espinoza LR. Autoimmune hepatitis and pregnancy: A Rheumatologist's dilemna. Sem. Arthrtis Rheum. (2005) 35(1): 49-56. DOI:10.1016/j.semarthrit.2005.03.002.