Review Article Open Access
Polymorphism: The Phenomenon Affecting the Performance of Drugs
Kaisar Raza1*, Pramod Kumar1, Shanti Ratan1, Ruchi Malik1 and Shweta Arora2
1 Department of Pharmacy, School of Chemical Sciences & Pharmacy, Central University of Rajasthan, Bandar Sindri, India-305817
2 Central Scientific Instruments Organization, Chandigarh, India-160030
*Corresponding author: Kaisar Raza, Assistant Professor, Department of Pharmacy, School of Chemical Sciences & Pharmacy, Central University of Rajasthan, Rajasthan, India, 305817; E-mail: @
Received: June 02, 2014, Accepted: July 17, 2014, Published: July 28, 2014
Citation: Raza K, Kumar P, Ratan S, Malik R, Arora S (2014) Polymorphism: The Phenomenon Affecting the Performance of Drugs. SOJ Pharm Pharm Sci, 1(2), 10. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15226/2374-6866/1/2/00111
Abstract Top
Polymorphism is the ability of solid materials to exist in two or more crystalline forms with different arrangements or conformations of the constituents in the crystal lattice. These polymorphic forms of a drug differ in the physicochemical properties like dissolution and solubility, chemical and physical stability, flowability and hygroscopicity. These forms also differ in various important drug outcomes like drug efficacy, bioavailability, and even toxicity. Polymorphic studies are important as a particular polymorph can be responsible for a particular property which might not be exhibited by any other form. This review will discuss the applied nature of polymorphism starting from their preparation, characterization and pharmaceutical importance with a special emphasis on drugs.

Keywords: Crystal forms, Crystallization, Raman spectroscopy, XRD, Crystallography
IntroductionTop
The term polymorph has been derived from a Greek word “poly”, which means “many”, and “morph” “implying “form””. Hence, polymorphism refers to different structural forms of a chemical substance. It is defined as the ability of a solid material to exist in two or more crystalline forms with different arrangements or conformations in the crystal lattice. More than 50% of active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) are estimated to have more than one polymorphic form [1,2]. Polymorphism and pseudomorphism are very common amongst drugs and are responsible for differences in many properties [3]. Generally, polymorphism is considered to be of two types, viz. monotropic systems and enantiotropic systems. In the former type, only one polymorphic form is stable at the temperatures below the melting point of the solid drug. However, in the latter, no such phenomenon is observed, though different forms can be stable than the others irrespective of any noticeable temperature pattern. These forms exhibit a temperature, where two polymorphic forms have same free energy, termed as transition temperature [4,5]. Though chemically same, the polymorphs have different lattice structures and subsequently differ in the physicochemical properties. Table 1 enlists various physiochemical and pharmaceutical properties, which are the functions of polymorphism of the APIs [6].
For the compounds exhibiting polymorphism, the knowledge of the thermodynamic stability and thermokinetics is desired for the better understanding of the transformations and the time span required for these transformations [7]. Existence of two basic polymorphic forms, viz. monotropes and enantiotropes is assumed on these bases. The relative stability and driving force for the polymorphic transformations at constant temperature and pressure is determined by Gibbs free energy (ΔG); the internal energy available for chemical work [8], as portrayed by equation 1:
$△G=△H−T△S MathType@MTEF@5@5@+= feaagKart1ev2aaatCvAUfeBSjuyZL2yd9gzLbvyNv2CaerbuLwBLn hiov2DGi1BTfMBaeXatLxBI9gBaerbd9wDYLwzYbItLDharqqtubsr 4rNCHbGeaGqiVu0Je9sqqrpepC0xbbL8F4rqqrFfpeea0xe9Lq=Jc9 vqaqpepm0xbba9pwe9Q8fs0=yqaqpepae9pg0FirpepeKkFr0xfr=x fr=xb9adbaqaaeGaciGaaiaabeqaamaabaabaaGcbaGaeS4SLyLaam 4raiabg2da9iabloBjwjaadIeacqGHsislcaWGubGaeS4SLyLaam4u aaaa@4070@$
Where ΔH signifies the enthalpy change, while ΔS accounts for the entropy change. Negative value of ΔG assures the spontaneity of the polymorphic transitions, whereas the positive value renders the process non-spontaneous. Figure 1 depicts the influence of various thermokinetic and thermodynamic parameters on the molecular attributes resulting in polymorphic transitions. The graphs between ΔG versus temperature give the quantitative information about the stability of polymorphs. The former can be easily extracted from various studies viz. melting point, enthalpy of transformation (if available), enthalpy of fusion, and the van’t Hoff plots. The data obtained from melting point is relatively easy to generate as it requires less quantity of the substance vis- à-vis the van’t Hoff solubility studies. On contrary, it also poses the challenge of potential chemical degradation induced by high temperature. The latter method offers the advantage of studying the possibility for solution-mediated transformations or solvate formation during solubility measurement over a considerable temperature range and various solvent systems [8-10].
Pseudopolymorphs, i.e., co-crystals are also studied along with polymorphism, which are solid crystalline materials comprising two or more molecules or atoms in the same crystal lattice [11]. Co-crystals are also generally characterized as hydrates (solvent trapped), solvates (solvent present), and clathrates (molecules trapped) [12]. The first co-crystals reported were the co-crystals of hydroquinone and quinone in 1844 by Friedrich Wöhle [13]. Co-crystals directly affect the solid-state properties in terms of solubility and bioavailability. Co-crystals are
Figure 1: Pictorial representations of the inter-relationship of the thermodynamic and thermokinetic parameters on the solid-state transformations[ 8].
frequently designed for pharmaceutical formulations and many pharmaceutical products like tropomyosin and troponin, have been already designed by virtue of the co-crystal phenomenon [14]. For better understanding, various solid state arrangements pertinent to polymorphs and co-crystals have been portrayed in Figure 2. The stereochemistry of the polymorphs and pseudopolymorphs is also a crucial parameter. The molecular dissymmetry and chirality associated is now being employed in the pharmaceutical drug development. Racemic mixtures are frequently characterized by their melting point phase diagram [15]. Each optically active compound has different pharmacological activity and it has been proved that chirality with dissymmetry, directly affects the pharmacological activity [16].
The difference in the thermodynamic, as well as other properties of various polymorphs, ranges from minute to significant difference; implying the various degrees of transformation of one form to another. The metastable forms are thermodynamically unstable and can easily transform to the low energy and thermodynamically stable forms. Henceforth, it is crucial to perform suitable polymorphic selection for each active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) and select the most stable polymorph for the product development. The most stable polymorph should be employed in the marketed formulation to prevent polymorphic alterations during manufacturing, delivery, or storage. In general, the selected polymorph should be thermodynamically stable during the drug development process and remain stable during the manufacturing process too [17]. In this context, various federal agencies require the appropriate description of the solid state of the API employed in the formulation [18]. Table 2 illustrates a few drugs whose polymorphic forms have been analyzed.
As far as dosage form development is concerned, following general rules are advised for the APIs which show polymorphism: (a) Selection of the lowest energy polymorph as it is the most thermodynamically stable form; (b) Avoidance of the metastable forms, though they are more physically stable, but chemically less stable. Attempts should be made to play with the excipients to achieve the set pharmaceutical goals, instead of selecting the metastable form; (c) Maintenance of such conditions which will avoid transitions from metastable form to the stable form throughout the shelf-life of the product, if the former form is selected due to a particular reason like bioavailability enhancement; (d) Assurance of avoidance of any polymorphic transition in the dosage form throughout its shelf-life, if so, the same should not significantly affect the product quality and bioavailability [19, 20].
Figure 2: Pictorial representation (a) Amorphous form (b) Crystalline form (c) Hydrates and Solvates (d) Clathrates O Drug molecule * Solvent molecule OTrapped drug molecule
Methods of Polymorph PreparationTop
Most of the polymorphic transitions occur spontaneously or by induction of some specific conditions, and generally require a complete solid-state characterization of the API and the excipients. Now-a-days, there is an increased interest between the formulation and medicinal scientists to explore the various possibilities of the polymorphic transitions in-situ and exformulation, generally as a component of preformulation studies. Therefore, many new methods have been investigated to induce the polymorphic transitions and this section will discuss a few most employed ones in brief. Figure 3 highlights the frequently reported methods for the polymorphic transitions in the APIs or so-called methods to prepare polymorphs.Most of these methods are neither novel nor new, but extension of the routinely employed crystallization techniques for various organic molecules including proteins. Table 3 provides a general comparison between these methods for a quick reference.
Solvent evaporation method (Rota Evaporation)Top
In this approach, the saturated solution of the drug is prepared in an appropriate solvent and the solvent is removed by rotatory evaporation. Air drying at various temperatures, can also be employed to obtain different potential polymorphs [41].
Slow cooling approachTop
This technique is frequently employed for the polymorphic forms of less soluble drugs in the solvent systems having boiling point range of 30 to 90°C. In brief, the solute is heated in the solvent just above the boiling point of the latter to produce the saturated solution. This solution is transferred to a stoppered tube and is connected to a Dewar flask containing water at a temperature just below the boiling point of the solvent. The Dewar flask is left in these conditions for several days. This technique may further be improved to obtain better crystal forms using different solvent mixtures of different polarities. Variation in the solvent composition may inhibit or promote growth of particular crystal faces and hence, can yield crystals of the desired morphology. This approach is also called the solution growth approach [42,43].
Solvent diffusion techniqueTop
This method is employed when the amount of drug available is less, and the drug is sensitive to air and/or solvent(s). In this
Table 1: Physicochemical and Pharmaceutical Properties of APIs influenced by Various Polymorphic Forms.
 Crystal habit, Morphology, Hygroscopy, Tabletability Refractive index/Optical Properties/Melting point Enthalpy, Spectral Vibrational Transitions Dissolution rate, Molar volume and density Stability, Compatibility, Hardness, , Intrinsic solubility Handling, Flowability, Blending, and Bioavailability
option, the solution is placed in a sample tube; subsequently a less dense solvent is carefully dripped down the sides of the tube using either a pipette or a syringe to form a discreet layer. The slow diffusion of the solvent results in the crystallization of API at the interface. Most employed solvent combination is CH2 Cl2 / ethanol and is preferred one, provided the sample is insoluble in ether [44].
Vapor diffusion methodTop
This method is analogous to the previous one and is also applicable for the less quantities of the sample. In this case, the concentrated drug solution (0.5 μL to approximately 20 μL) is placed as a drop hanging on the underside of a microscope cover slip. The cover slip with the hanging drop is sealed with silicon oil over a solution (approx. 1 mL; reservoir) containing high concentration of precipitant. Due to higher precipitant concentration, the latter has lower vapor pressure than the drug solution. This results in diffusion of the solvent from the drop towards the reservoir and subsequent crystallization of the API within hours to weeks [45].
Table 2: List of Various Drugs Studied for Polymorphism [21-50].
 S. No. Name of the API Number of Polymorphic forms Bioavailable form Advantages and significance 1 Cortisone acetate [21] 5 I stable 2 Methylprednisolone [22] 2 I Higher dissolution 3 Sulphamethoxydiazine [23] 3 III Water stable form 4 Chlortetracycline [24] 2 (alpha and beta form) Beta form Absorbs faster in GIT 5 Phenylbutazone [25] 5 IV Most Stable Form 6 6-Mercaptopurine [26] 3 III Absorbs more efficiently from GIT in comparison to form I 7 Amobarbitol [27] 2 II Dissolution rate is high 8 Metoprolol tartrate [28] 2 I & II Better tabletability , compressibility and stability 9 Phenobarbitone [29] 6 I, II, IV(Form D), VI More stability 10 Tolbutamide [30] 4 II and IV High solubility, dissolution and oral absorption 11 Furosemide [31] 2 I Photochemical stability 12 Carbamazepine [32 - 34] 3 I and III Less degradation 13 Phenobarbital [35] 6 A,B and F More stability 14 paracetamol [36-38] 2 II Good compressibility and plastic deformation properties 15 Cimetidine [39] 4 I and III Thermodynamically more stable, Higher dissolution rate of polymorphs III vis-à-vis form I 16 Sulfathiazole [40] 3 I Stable 17 Sulfamerazine [41] 2 I Greater tensile strength, tabletability and compresibility 18 Enalapril maleate [42] 2 II Thermo-chemically stable 19 Pramocaine [43] 2 I More stable 20 Diflunisal [44] 4 IV High crystal density and intermolecular interactions 21 Chloramphenicol Palmitate [45] 3 II Thermodynamically stable and better bioavailability 22 Indomethacin [46] 3 I &  II Higher therapeutic efficiency 23 Huperzine [47] 3 III Most thermodynamically stable under various conditions, higher solubility than the marketed formulations 24 Famotidine [48] 3 II Metastable and commercially available 25 Efavirenz [49] 6 I More thermodynamically stable 26 Barbital [50] 6 III Metastable, high kinetic stability  and commercially available
Vacuum sublimationTop
Sublimation is known to offer excellent crystals of variety of compounds, especially. the air sensitive ones.This approach is frequently employed to induce crystallization with numerous variations of static or dynamic vacuum. A small amount of sample sealed under vacuum in a reactor is generally subject to a temperature gradient in numerous manners. Temperature of the order of 250°C can be easily employed at a pressure of around 10-2 mm of Hg. The crystals grow from the wall to the center of the reactor [43,46].
Crystal engineering and supramolecular synthesis (cocrystallization) are being used to enhance solubility, bioavailability, safety and efficacy of various APIs [57]. For instance, glutaric acid co-crystals with 2-[4-(4- chloro-2-fluorophenoxy) phenyl] pyrimidine-4-carboxamide have been developed and possess the marked potential to enhance the bioavailability [58]. Various techniques have been employed to control the polymorphism, like high throughput crystallization method, capillary growth method, laser-induced nucleation, and hetero nucleation on single crystal substrates [8]. High throughput crystallization methods have been developed to screen various conditions like temperature, concentration and solvent combinations. This screening pattern of polymorphs provides an atlas to develop the suitable form [59]. Polymorphs of ritonavir have been developed by high throughput screening methods [60]. Super saturation ratio is an influential parameter for the metastable crystal formation in a solution as well as in capillary. Capillary growth methods are frequently employed techniques to control polymorphism and during the process itself, the crystals can be analyzed in a capillary tube. Nabumetone metastable polymorphs have been reported to be developed by the capillary growth methods [61]. Non-photochemical laser-induced nucleation method has been used in supersaturated solutions of glycine and urea to result in the metastable polymorphs [62-63]. Heteronucleation on single crystal substrates is a crystallization technique used to prepare stable polymorphs by adding polymers in nucleation reaction [64]. Carbamazepine polymorphic form IV has been developed by this method [65].
Characterization techniquesTop
Various techniques have been used to characterize the polymorphs like thermal analysis (differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), thermogravimetric analysis (TGA)), infrared (Fourier Transform Infrared- FT-IR) spectroscopy, Raman spectroscopy, powder X-ray diffraction (XRD), single crystal XRD, solid state NMR, tetrahertz spectroscopy, optical and electron microscopy, and incoherent inelastic neutron scattering (IINS). Thermal properties of polymorphs are an important aspect and are generally fetched by DSC and TGA [66-68]. Thermal properties of polymorphs are an important aspect and are generally fetched by DSC and TGA [66- 68]. FT-IR helps to identify the polymorphs by indicating changes in frequencies, relative intensities, band contours and the number of bands. Difference in spectra gives an inference to the internal arrangement of crystals [69-70]. Raman spectroscopy is analogous to FT-IR spectroscopy and is considered an ideal nondestructive tool for polymorphic studies. As far as distinction of various polymorphs and amorphous forms is considered, Raman spectroscopy offers better spectral selectivity [71-72]. XRD is the most widely employed and reliable technique to identify different crystal phases through different diffraction patterns. Changes in XRD pattern as may be new peak, shoulders, or a shift provides the proof of polymorphic transitions [73]. Single crystal XRD is a nondestructive technique, which provides internal lattice information of crystalline substances, as well as the unit cell parameters like bond length, bond angle and unit cell type [74]. Solid state NMR is a relatively newer, tough powerful tool to study crystalline polymorphs, relative crystallinity and amorphous content of pharmaceutical mixtures. This technique provides information about local structure of selected atoms/ nuclei. [44,75]. Terahertz pulsed spectroscopy (TPS) and terahertz pulsed imaging (TPI) are the techniques based on the utilization of the spectral information obtained in the far infrared region of the electromagnetic spectrum. These techniques
Table 3: Rational for choice/selection of the methods for the preparation of polymorphs [51-56]
 S. No. Method Characteristics Advantages Disadvantages Pharmaceutical examples 1 Rota evaporation [51] Applicable for high melting substances High purity and yield Desirability of recrystallization, small production volume and expensive Famotidine 2 Slow cooling approach [52,53] First choice due to the ease and simplicity Large scale production and easily reproducible Low yield, higher input, chances of disordered/twinned crystals Sodium chloride, copper sulfate 3 Solvent diffusion technique [54] Best for less quantity of substance and the materials sensitive to air and moisture Larger surface area, higher solubility, high mechanical strength to crystals Low production yield, tedious solvent selection Tolbutamide, Pentacene and 6,13-Pentacenequinone, 4 Vapor diffusion method [55] Requires less amount of sample Less quantity of sample for crystallization Time consuming, difficult solvent selection, expensive and low yield Proteins 5 Vacuum sublimation method [53-56] Desired when quantity is less and the sample is thermolabile Excellent crystal variety Disordered or twinned crystals Haloprogin
are now being employed for the physical characterization of pharmaceutical solids. The spectral interpretation and the basic instrumentation are analogous to that of FT-IR and Raman spectroscopy. It gives information on low-frequency intermolecular vibrational modes, which are difficult to be assessed in Raman spectroscopy owing to the closeness of the laser exciting line [76-78]. Optical and electron microscopy provide the visible differences in topography and the structure of the crystal forms [72]. Recently, Tsapatsaris et al. employed IINS for the study of monoclinic and orthorhombic polymorphs of paracetamol and reported interesting findings [79]. Hot stage microscopy part of light microscopy is one of the oldest and powerful techniques to characterize the phase transitions of crystals as well as the optical properties. Temperature variations induced while microscopic view assists in the formation as well as detection of another crystal form(s). Nicotinamide and many more other crystal forms have been successfully studied employing hot stage microscopy [80]. Crystal forms differ from each other in size and shape, and this difference can be easily observed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) [81].
Crystal structure prediction is a challenging task in crystallography. Computational prediction of polymorphs is many-a-times beneficial in the drug designing, screening of active forms and stable polymorphs as well as other properties including thermodynamics. Zero order models, CCDC (Cambridge crystallographic data centre) and blind tests are the recent computational techniques which are being used to predict the crystal structures [81, 82]. Older and newer aspirin polymorphs have been successfully predicted by these approaches and the newer developed polymorph is relatively more stable and active than the existing one [83-85].
Evaluation TechniquesTop
Dissolution studyTop
This study is generally performed in a suitable dissolution medium, generally phosphate buffer saline, pH 7.4. The timedependent solubility studies are performed and the dissolution profile of various polymorphs is compared. The dissolution pattern can be correlated with the enthalpies of fusion and melting point [86].
Temperature Dependent Solubility of Polymorphs: van’t Hoff PlotTop
van’t Hoff plot is an important approach to determine the values of dissolution enthalpy (ΔH) and dissolution entropy (ΔS), as per the equation 2:

$(lnsolubility)=−(△H/RT)+(△S/R) MathType@MTEF@5@5@+= feaagKart1ev2aaatCvAUfeBSjuyZL2yd9gzLbvyNv2CaerbuLwBLn hiov2DGi1BTfMBaeXatLxBI9gBaerbd9wDYLwzYbItLDharqqtubsr 4rNCHbGeaGqiVu0Je9sqqrpepC0xbbL8F4rqqrFfpeea0xe9Lq=Jc9 vqaqpepm0xbba9pwe9Q8fs0=yqaqpepae9pg0FirpepeKkFr0xfr=x fr=xb9adbaqaaeGaciGaaiaabeqaamaabaabaaGcbaGaaiikaiGacY gacaGGUbGaam4Caiaad+gaciGGSbGaaiyDaiaackgacaWGPbGaamiB aiaadMgacaWG0bGaamyEaiaacMcacqGH9aqpcqGHsislcaGGOaGaeS 4SLyLaamisaiaac+cacaWGsbGaamivaiaacMcacqGHRaWkcaGGOaGa eS4SLyLaam4uaiaac+cacaWGsbGaaiykaaaa@514B@$ For the same, saturated solubilities at least three temperatures are determined and graph between loge of molar solubility and inverse of absolute temperature is plotted. The slope fetches with the enthalpy of dissolution, while the intercept provides the value change in entropy, as per equation 1 [48, 87].
Biological studiesTop
There are reports on the biological evaluation of the polymorphs in the specific animal model. For instance, Nagaraju et al. prepared polymorphs of famotidine and also evaluated them for antiulcer activity employing pylorus ligation model. They reported better in vivo performance of a particular polymorph vis-à-vis the pure drug [48]. These types of studies are important as they can provide proper understanding about the biological fate alterations owing to the physical form transitions. However, these studies are drug-type specific and are more significant for the stable polymorphic forms.Various physiochemical properties are responsible for failure of compounds in various preclinical and clinical stages. Polymorphic studies are crucial as these forms play a vital role in preclinical/clinical development.
Importance in Pharmaceutical SciencesTop
Polymorphism is an influential phenomenon especially in pharmaceutical sciences, as it can significantly influence variety of API properties including flowability, tableting, dissolution rate, solubility, stability and even biological performance including efficacy and toxicity [4, 88-90]. List of a few drugs explored for polymorphic transitions have already been listed in Table 2. Literature is occupied with several examples dictating the influence of physical arrangement on various physiochemical and biological attributes of drugs and excipients. For instance, Wille et al. reported six polymorphs of cocoa butter and all the polymorphs have significantly different melting points. Hence, selection of a particular polymorphic form and prevention of intervention is crucial for development of formulations based on this excipient [91]. Nagaraju et al. prepared polymorphs of famotidine by solvent evaporation method. They reported that PVP polymorphs of famotidine offered better dissolution behavior and antiulcer effect vis-à-vis pure famotidine and its methanol polymorph [51]. Zhang et al. developed two polymorphs of lornoxicam, out of which the form II (orthorhombic form) offered higher solubility and exhibited higher dissolution rate. Henceforth, it was regarded as a better option for oral and injectable dosage forms of the drug [92]. Yadav et al. studied five different polymorphic forms of pefloxacin reported the crystal forms of pefloxacin. Interestingly, all the forms offered high dissolution behavior within 15 min, which was further stabilized to a constant value after 4 hours [93]. Polymorphic forms are established to alter the biological distribution and efficacy of chloramphenicol palmitate [94], phenylbutazone [95], amobarbitol [27], cimetidine[96], 6-mercaptopurine[26] and chlortetracycline hydrochloride [24]; though established in animal models [97]. Despite preclinical studies, various clinical studies employing polymorphic forms of a variety of drugs is easily traceable. Examples include enhanced absorption of chloramphenicol palmitate and comparable bioavailability mefenamic acid polymorphs [98, 99, 97]. For more details, one can refer to the review by Singhal et al [97]. Taking cognizance to this level of understanding, now-adays there are serious regulatory concerns pertaining to the physiochemical properties, stability and product performance of the pharmaceuticals prone to show polymorphism. The variations in the outcomes due to polymorphs are more vis-à-vis plain drug, and hence, are demanded to be incorporated in the dossiers being filed to regulatory bodies [100].
Figure 3: General Methods to Prepare Polymorphs.
ConclusionsTop
In the present era of evolving understanding, it is accepted that not merely chemical purity/integrity of the API is the sole dependable and formulation influential parameter. The physical arrangements of the constituents’ in the crystal lattice have immense potential to influence the physicochemical properties of the drugs and subsequently the therapeutic outcomes. Therefore, the study of polymorphic forms has become as important as any other branch of pharmaceutical sciences, as the former helps to embark upon the proper API/excipient form selection. This understanding will not only enhance the shelf-life of the product, but will help to maintain the potency, as planned/desired. On the regulatory fronts too, now-a-days there are concerns and guidelines to have clarity on the polymorphic transitions of the API as well as the potential excipients and the relevant information is mandate of the dossier filings to US-FDA and other federal agencies. Myriad of analytical techniques are available to study these minute transitions which can influence the overall performance of the pharmaceuticals. Simple spectroscopic techniques like FT-IR and Raman can be of the utmost importance. Many varieties of drugs are still unexplored for polymorphism and offer a huge scope for further research in a holistic manner.
ReferencesTop

Listing : ICMJE

Open Access by Symbiosis is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License