Review Article
Open Access
Some Attempted Strategies towards the Control
of Avian Coccidiosis: A Review
Kaze Paul Davou1*, Idris Lawal2, Ajanusi Joseph2 and Saidu Lawal3
1Department of Veterinary Parasitology and Entomology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Jos, Nigeria.
2Department of Veterinary Parasitology and Entomology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria.
3Department of Veterinary Medicine, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria.
2Department of Veterinary Parasitology and Entomology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria.
3Department of Veterinary Medicine, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria.
*Corresponding author: Kaze Paul Davou, Department of Veterinary Parasitology and Entomology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Jos, Nigeria. Tel: +234 8028042436; E-mail:
@
Received: May 04, 2018; Accepted: June 20, 2018; Published: July 26, 2018
Citation: Paul Davou K, Idris L, Joseph A, Saidu L (2018) Some Attempted Strategies towards the Control of Avian Coccidiosis: A Review. SOJ Immunol 6(2): 1-11. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15226/2372-0948/6/2/00169
Abstract
his paper focuses on anticoccidial drugs and resistance, poultry
management, alternatives for anticoccidial drugs including dietary
modulation, natural additives and herbs comprising of botanicals
to coccidia. The paper also viewed at the treatment programme for
coccidiosis control as well as its potential implications in meat tissue
to man.
Keywords: Anticoccidial drugs; Avian Coccidiosis; Coccidiostats
Keywords: Anticoccidial drugs; Avian Coccidiosis; Coccidiostats
Introduction
Anticoccidial feed additives have been used for more than 50
years to remedy or treat coccidiosis in poultry [1] and the aim
of the paper was to review some attempted strategies employed
towards the control of avian coccidiosis. Coocidiosis causes
annual losses of US $ 2.4 billion to the poultry industry worldwide
[2] in both the layer and broiler industries. Conventional disease
control strategies depend on vaccination and proplylactic use
of anticoccidial drugs. However, resistance against anticoccidial
compounds is widely spread and coccidiostats as feed additives
was banned in Europe by the year 2012 [Regulation [EC] No
1831/2003 of the European parliament and of the council of 22
September, 2003 on additives for use in animal nutrition]
Anticoccidial Drugs
These are synthesized drugs, which include variant groups of
completely different chemical classes:
1. Amprolium is good against E. tenella but is not very effective against E.acervulina and E. maxima.
2. Nicarbazin is a broad-spectrum anticoccidial, it is used in colder seasons or climatic areas and the drugs should not be used in birds older than 20 days because the possibility of strong growth depression. - Robendine is safe broad-spectrum anticoccidial but it must be used with caution because of it’s potential fast resistance build up.
3. Halofuginone and Lerbek effects on E. tenella are coccidiostatic activity and no coccidiocidal effect, but good for control of E. acevurlina.
4. Clinacox [Dicluzuril]. This has a broad-spectrum activity against all Eimeria species. The potential of Eimeria species, especially Eimeria tenella and Eimeria maxima to develop resistance to the drug is low. It is also used for “clean-up” program after the use of ionophore [3].
1. Amprolium is good against E. tenella but is not very effective against E.acervulina and E. maxima.
2. Nicarbazin is a broad-spectrum anticoccidial, it is used in colder seasons or climatic areas and the drugs should not be used in birds older than 20 days because the possibility of strong growth depression. - Robendine is safe broad-spectrum anticoccidial but it must be used with caution because of it’s potential fast resistance build up.
3. Halofuginone and Lerbek effects on E. tenella are coccidiostatic activity and no coccidiocidal effect, but good for control of E. acevurlina.
4. Clinacox [Dicluzuril]. This has a broad-spectrum activity against all Eimeria species. The potential of Eimeria species, especially Eimeria tenella and Eimeria maxima to develop resistance to the drug is low. It is also used for “clean-up” program after the use of ionophore [3].
Sulfonamide Products
The drug exerted a major impact on the worldwide
production of poultry meat [4]. Veterinarians and Animal
scientist regularly use sulfonamides for therapeutic and
prophylactic. Sulfadimethoxine, and sulfaquinoxaline are mainly
used for prevention or treatment of poultry coccidiosis, and are
generally co-administered in feed. The treatment of hens with
sulfonamides-supplemented feed may result in sulfonamides
residues being present in market eggs if these drugs have been
improperly administered or if the withdrawal time for the
treated hens has not been observed. To assure the food safety for
consumers, the European Union has set a maximum residue limit
for sulfonamides in foods of animal origin such as meat, milk,
and eggs [5]. Misuse of these veterinary drugs in laying hens is of
great concerns because the drug residues are turning up in eggs,
which is an indispensable food for the consumers because it is
highly nutritious, cheap and readily available.
A strong residue monitoring of sulfonamides in eggs is thus an important specific activity to guarantee the food safety. Removing the waste of organic solvents is also a serious problem on the world scale. From the view point of the effect of organic solvents to environments and analysts, analytical methods for the monitoring should avoid the use of organic solvents [6, 7]. The feeding of 2,500 parts per million [ppm] sulfaquinoxaline causes a severe anemia in chickens with hemorrhages on the legs, breast muscle, and in abdominal organs [8]. Toxicity is more likely to be observed when medication is given in the water during hot weather. Feeding 300- ppm sulfaquinoxaline to growing chickens for 8 weeks reduced the weight gain of female birds but adverse, effects were not observed when sulfaquinoxaline was administered to growing chickens at 300-ppm in various feeding schedules. Continuous feeding of 125-ppm sulfaquinoxaline was highly efficacious in preventing naturally acquired caecal and intestinal coccidiosis. The total efficacy benefits of sulfaquinoxaline in comparison with other sulfonamides were associated to the fact that it is more readily absorbed than other sulfonamides when given in the feed.
A strong residue monitoring of sulfonamides in eggs is thus an important specific activity to guarantee the food safety. Removing the waste of organic solvents is also a serious problem on the world scale. From the view point of the effect of organic solvents to environments and analysts, analytical methods for the monitoring should avoid the use of organic solvents [6, 7]. The feeding of 2,500 parts per million [ppm] sulfaquinoxaline causes a severe anemia in chickens with hemorrhages on the legs, breast muscle, and in abdominal organs [8]. Toxicity is more likely to be observed when medication is given in the water during hot weather. Feeding 300- ppm sulfaquinoxaline to growing chickens for 8 weeks reduced the weight gain of female birds but adverse, effects were not observed when sulfaquinoxaline was administered to growing chickens at 300-ppm in various feeding schedules. Continuous feeding of 125-ppm sulfaquinoxaline was highly efficacious in preventing naturally acquired caecal and intestinal coccidiosis. The total efficacy benefits of sulfaquinoxaline in comparison with other sulfonamides were associated to the fact that it is more readily absorbed than other sulfonamides when given in the feed.
Ionophore Products
Ionophores are the major group of poultry feed additives
the polyether antibiotics commonly called Ionophores. Six
compounds have become available [Monensin, Laslocid,
Salinomycin , Narasin , Maduramycin and Semduramycin ], the
mechanism of action of all ionophores is very similar since they
mediate the transport of mono and divalent cations throw the
membrane of the parasite, resulting in disturbance of its osmotic
balance. Ionphores can be divided into three groups according
to the precise of action and chemical structure; monovalent
[Monensin, Narasin and Salinomycin], monovalent glycoside
[Maduramycin and Semduramycin] and divalent [Laslocid].
Laslocid and Maduramycin are more effective against E. tenella
than Monensin, Narasin and Salinomycin [3].
Polyether Ionophors
They are produced by fermentation of Streptomyces or
Actinomadura and they are the most widely used agents, such as
salinomycin, monensin, lasalocid and narasin. They act through
a general mechanism of changing ion transport and disrupting
osmotic balance in the parasite.
Mode of Action of Anticoccidial Drugs
The biochemical effects of anticoccidials are numerous, but
each class of chemical compound is unique in the type of action
exerted on the parasite and its development stage. Different
modes of action have been observed and this can be divided into
different broad categories, according to Chapman [1997] [9] and
McDougald [2003].
Drugs that Affect Cofactor Synthesis
Several drugs affect biochemical pathways that are
dependent upon an important cofactor. For instance, amprolium
competitively inhibits the uptake of thiamine by the parasite.
Drugs that Affect Mitochondrial Function
These drugs inhibit energy metabolism in the cytochrome
system of the Eimeria. For instance, quinolones and clopidol
inhibit electron transport in the parasite mitochondrion, but by
different pathways.
Drugs that Affect Membrane Function
Ionophores in common have the ability to form lipophylic
complexes with alkaline metal cations [Na+, K+, and Ca++] and
transport these cations through the cell membrane and then
affect a range of processes that depend upon ion transport, such
as influx of sodium ions thus, causing severe osmotic damage.
These drugs act against the extracellular stages of the life cycle
of the Eimeria.
Resistance to Anticoccidial Drugs
In 1963, the World Health Organization [WHO] defined
resistance as “ability of a parasite strain to multiply or to survive
in the presence of concentrations of a drug that normally destroy
parasites of the same species or prevents their multiplication”.
Resistance may be relative [increasing doses of the drug being
tolerated by the host] or complete [maximum doses being
tolerated by the host] [10]. Anticoccidial drugs added to the feed
are a good preventive measure and are well adapted to largescale
use, but continuous use of these drugs leads inevitably
to the emergence of Eimeria strains that are resistant to all
anticoccidial drugs, including ionophores [1]. Resistance can
develop quickly, as in the case of quinolones and clopidol, or it
may take several years for the Coccidia to become tolerant, as in
the case of polyether ionophores [11].
Origin of Resistance Anticoccidial Drugs
There are three key factors contributing to drug resistance in
commercial poultry production [12]:
• The intense and the continuous use of anticoccidial drugs in the poultry industry providing the basis for changing gene frequency through genetic selection.
• Coccidia are ubiquitous in poultry facilities and the large reproductive potential forms a large reservoir of genetic variation, which leads to the development of drug resistance.
• The life cycle of Eimeria is complex and involves a period of asexual and sexual stages. The nuclei of the asexual stage of Eimeria contain haploid complement chromosomes. Most drugs are active against this haploid stage, resulting in the removal of the most sensitive ones. This enables the more resistant ones to increase and thus rapidly becoming the dominant phenotype that spreads through the parasite population.
• The intense and the continuous use of anticoccidial drugs in the poultry industry providing the basis for changing gene frequency through genetic selection.
• Coccidia are ubiquitous in poultry facilities and the large reproductive potential forms a large reservoir of genetic variation, which leads to the development of drug resistance.
• The life cycle of Eimeria is complex and involves a period of asexual and sexual stages. The nuclei of the asexual stage of Eimeria contain haploid complement chromosomes. Most drugs are active against this haploid stage, resulting in the removal of the most sensitive ones. This enables the more resistant ones to increase and thus rapidly becoming the dominant phenotype that spreads through the parasite population.
Poultry House Management
The high standard of flock hygiene, sanitation and poultry
farm management helps in achieving optimal benefit from the
use of anticoccidial drugs in preventing coccidiosis [9]. However,
the sanitary practice alone is inadequate for complete removal of
coccidial oocysts. This is because of the following:
• There have been too many failures in sanitary programs
• Oocysts are extremely resistant to common disinfectants
• House sterilization is never complete
• An oocyst-sterile environment for floor-maintained birds could prevent early establishment of immunity and thus allow late outbreaks [11].
• There have been too many failures in sanitary programs
• Oocysts are extremely resistant to common disinfectants
• House sterilization is never complete
• An oocyst-sterile environment for floor-maintained birds could prevent early establishment of immunity and thus allow late outbreaks [11].
Alternative for Anticoccidial Drugs
The constant and extensive use of the anticoccidial drugs
for prevention and control of coccidiosis in poultry has been a
major factor in the success of the industry. This beneficial use
of anticoccidial drugs is associated with a widespread drug
resistance of Coccidia in the United States, South America and
Europe [11]. The first step of defense against development of
resistance is the use of shuttle or dual programs [two or more
drugs employed within a single flock] and frequent rotation of
drugs [rotation of different compounds between flocks] [11]. The
awareness by the consumers to avoid chemotherapeutics, the
high development costs and low profits have not encouraged the
pharmaceutical industry to develop new anticoccidial products
[9]. Thus, alternatives progressively and currently been sought.
Dietary Modulation of Coccidia
The study of the interactions between diet composition and
Coccidia is of great interest. Before the availability of effective
anticoccidial drugs, recommendations for coccidial control
included the formulation of diets that were considered capable of
reducing the severity of infection such as diets containing skimmed
milk, buttermilk, or whey [13]. But due to the development of the
efficient, low-cost anticoccidial drugs caused lesser interest in
dietary modulation. However, with the appearance of resistance
to coccidiostats, the consumers’ concern, and the expected
regulations to ban the coccidiostats in the future, the possible
role of nutrition has recently attracted interest [14].
Vitamins and minerals
Many vitamins change the immune status and the resistance
of the host against Eimeria infections. Many works reported
that vitamin A deficiency depresses T-lymphocyte response
to mutagens [15] and reduces specific antibody production
to protein antigens. Recently, [16] reported that vitamin A
deficiency in chickens caused alteration in the IEL subpopulation,
reduced the local cell-mediated immunity, and lowered the ability
of birds to resist E. acervulina infection. Vitamin E and selenium
generally improve resistance to coccidiosis, improve weight gain
[El-Boushy, 1988], and reduce mortality due to E. tenella infection
[17].
Vitamin C is known to possess immunity-enhancing effects in chickens and positive effect on birds’ performance during coccidial challenge has been observed [18], but it had no effect on the lesion scores due to E. tenella or E. acervulina infection [19] found that feeding a diet with extra vitamins A, C, D3, K, and selenium had no beneficial effects on the performance of chickens with subclinical infection caused by E. maxima, and E. tenella. Additional, the authors reported that performance in the birds supplemented with vitamins was even poorer than in birds fed the control diet. These results are inconsistent with previous work of [17] who fed 0.025 or 0.50 mg Se/kg of diet, noted a reduced mortality, an increase in body weight, and improved resistance against E. tenella.
Vitamin C is known to possess immunity-enhancing effects in chickens and positive effect on birds’ performance during coccidial challenge has been observed [18], but it had no effect on the lesion scores due to E. tenella or E. acervulina infection [19] found that feeding a diet with extra vitamins A, C, D3, K, and selenium had no beneficial effects on the performance of chickens with subclinical infection caused by E. maxima, and E. tenella. Additional, the authors reported that performance in the birds supplemented with vitamins was even poorer than in birds fed the control diet. These results are inconsistent with previous work of [17] who fed 0.025 or 0.50 mg Se/kg of diet, noted a reduced mortality, an increase in body weight, and improved resistance against E. tenella.
Products Rich in N-3 Fatty Acid
The n-3 fatty acids are polyunsaturated fatty acids, the
major fatty acids being eicosapentaenoic acid [EPA] and
docosahexaenoic acid [DHA], found abundantly in fish oil,
and alpha-linolenic acid [ALA], being a major component of
flaxseed oil. Allen et al. [20-22], they reported that fish-liver oil
exerts favorable control on the course of coccidiosis. They also
worked on a series of experiments using fish oil, flaxseed oil and
flaxseed in diets fed to male chickens from day 1 of age through
3 weeks of age and challenged with E. tenella at 2 weeks of age.
The researchers reported a significant reduction in caecal lesion
scores and in the histological examination, a significant reduction
in the degree of parasitaization and retarded development of the
E. tenella parasite was observed. The suggested mode of action
is that the n-3 fatty acids infiltrate the tissues of the parasite,
which in turn become more susceptible to oxidative attack by
phagocytic cells.
Additionally, n-3 fatty acids have been shown to enhance the immune response in birds infected with E. tenella. However, little if any response was seen in the birds’ performance, which is of most importance in poultry production. The n-3 fatty acids were proven ineffective against moderate or severe infection with E. maxima, and did not counteract reduced body-weight gain and lesion scores. The reason for the differences in response between these two Eimeria species to dietary n-3 fatty acids is not yet known [23].
Additionally, n-3 fatty acids have been shown to enhance the immune response in birds infected with E. tenella. However, little if any response was seen in the birds’ performance, which is of most importance in poultry production. The n-3 fatty acids were proven ineffective against moderate or severe infection with E. maxima, and did not counteract reduced body-weight gain and lesion scores. The reason for the differences in response between these two Eimeria species to dietary n-3 fatty acids is not yet known [23].
Betaine Supplementation
Betaine supplementation has been shown to have positive
effects on the water balance of broiler chicks stressed by high
ambient temperature or coccidiosis [24], and to protect the cells
from osmotic stress, allowing them to continue regular metabolic
activities under conditions that would normally inactivate the
cell [25]. [26] reported that betaine, in combination with the
ionophore and salinomycin had a significant positive effect on the
performance of chickens infected with E. acervulina, E. maxima,
and E. tenella, the effect being greater than that mediated by
betaine or salinomycin alone. Moreover, the combination resulted
in a slight decrease in development and invasion of the epithelium
by E. acervulina, while there was an increase in the invasion of E.
tenella.
However, the diet supplemented with betaine alone decreased the invasion of E. acervulina and E. tenella as indicated by the number of sporozoites present in the intestinal epithelium after the challenge. Klasing et al. [2002] later clarified this effect when they found that chickens fed betaine had more lymphocytes in the epithelium and in the lamina propria during E. acervulina infection than those fed the diet without betaine. This effect of betaine could result in more effective clearance of sporozoites that explain the decreased numbers in the epithelium as reported by [26], while [27] found that betaine as a single feed supplement significantly improved chickens’ body weight and tended to reduce the feed conversion ratio during coccidiosis infection. When betaine was used in the combination with the ionophore narasine, betaine showed no effects on birds’ performance when Eimeria tenella was the major pathogenic species. The exact action of betaine is not fully understood. [26] suggested that betaine might increase performance in chickens infected by coccidiosis by inhibition of coccidial invasion and indirectly by supporting intestinal structure and function that could enhance the ability of the infected chickens to with stand coccidial infection.
However, the diet supplemented with betaine alone decreased the invasion of E. acervulina and E. tenella as indicated by the number of sporozoites present in the intestinal epithelium after the challenge. Klasing et al. [2002] later clarified this effect when they found that chickens fed betaine had more lymphocytes in the epithelium and in the lamina propria during E. acervulina infection than those fed the diet without betaine. This effect of betaine could result in more effective clearance of sporozoites that explain the decreased numbers in the epithelium as reported by [26], while [27] found that betaine as a single feed supplement significantly improved chickens’ body weight and tended to reduce the feed conversion ratio during coccidiosis infection. When betaine was used in the combination with the ionophore narasine, betaine showed no effects on birds’ performance when Eimeria tenella was the major pathogenic species. The exact action of betaine is not fully understood. [26] suggested that betaine might increase performance in chickens infected by coccidiosis by inhibition of coccidial invasion and indirectly by supporting intestinal structure and function that could enhance the ability of the infected chickens to with stand coccidial infection.
Whole Wheat
The use of whole grains in broiler feeds is a frequent practice
in Europe [28]. Many works indicated that offering broilers
a whole cereal grains and balanced pellets greatly reduced
the severity of infection with Eimeria as judged based on the
reduction in output of oocysts [29-34] investigated the effects of
whole wheat inclusion in broiler feeds with or without access to
grit, and they observed no significant differences in faecal oocyst
yields, lesion scores, or performance in birds infected with E.
tenella or E. maxima. They concluded that the decrease in output
of oocysts as caused by inclusion of whole cereals in the diet,
and observed in the previous experiments, was not due to the
increase in the viscosity of the digesta or the crushing of oocysts
by an active gizzard and that whole wheat addition to the diet of
broiler chickens provides no control of coccidiosis.
Exogenous enzymes
The use of exogenous enzymes in food processing started as
early as 1900 and the majority of the enzymes have been derived
from fermentation by microorganisms [35]. When broilers fed
diet rich in wheat, barley, oat, or rye, the presence of non-starch
polysaccharides [arabinoxylans and β-glucans] can give rise
to high viscosity in the small intestine thereby decreasing the
contact of endogenous digestive enzymes and its substrates. This
results in a decrease in absorption and broilers’ performance,
and increase in the size of the GIT, pancreas, and the liver [36,37]
reported an improvement in broilers’ performance, a reduction
in the size of digestive organs and the GIT size, and an increase in
the total volatile fatty acids in the caecum, when a wheat-based
diet was supplemented with the 200 mg exogenous enzymes
xylanase or β-glucanase per kg feed. Addition of exogenous
xylanase has been found to improve the performance and to
reduce ileal digesta viscosity in Eimeria-infected birds [38]. It
was concluded that intestinal viscosity and the size of the gizzard
might affect the severity of the Eimeria infection. However, others
did not observe effects of increased intestinal digesta viscosity
on the severity of the Eimeria infection, when a large increase in
viscosity was being induced by the inclusion of carboxymethyl
cellulose in the feed [19, 34].
Electromagnetic Fields
Electromagnetic fields [EMF] have been in use as therapeutic
modalities for at least 40 years. It is well known that selected
electromagnetic fields [EMF] can have beneficial effects on
bones, joints, and neurological disorders, as well as wound
healing [39]. Anti-inflammatory aspects of EMF exposure have
been reported to be due to the activation of A2A adenosine
receptors in human neutrophils [40]. Generally, inflammation is
characterized by massive infiltration of T lymphocytes, neutrophils
and macrophages into the damaged tissue [41].
In earlier studies, it has been reported that EMF mediate positive effects on wound healing, controlling the proliferation of inflammatory lymphocytes, and therefore demonstrating beneficial effects on inflammatory disease [42]. Many authors [42- 44] have discussed the effects initiated by various EMF signals and stated that EMF causes stress at the cellular level and that this leads to production of cytokines and consequently a biological response, including an immune response. Recently, [45] reported that exposure of broiler chickens to EMF antagonized the effects of coccidial infection in birds infected with a mixture of sporulated oocysts containing E. acervulina, E. maxima, and E. tenella. It was found that the severity of the intestinal lesions mediated by E. acervulina and E. maxima were reduced in the EMF-treated birds.
In earlier studies, it has been reported that EMF mediate positive effects on wound healing, controlling the proliferation of inflammatory lymphocytes, and therefore demonstrating beneficial effects on inflammatory disease [42]. Many authors [42- 44] have discussed the effects initiated by various EMF signals and stated that EMF causes stress at the cellular level and that this leads to production of cytokines and consequently a biological response, including an immune response. Recently, [45] reported that exposure of broiler chickens to EMF antagonized the effects of coccidial infection in birds infected with a mixture of sporulated oocysts containing E. acervulina, E. maxima, and E. tenella. It was found that the severity of the intestinal lesions mediated by E. acervulina and E. maxima were reduced in the EMF-treated birds.
Natural Additive and Herbs
A number of natural herbs have been tested as anticoccidial
dietary additives. Artemisinin isolated from Artemisia annua, is
a naturally occurring endoperoxide with antimalarial properties.
It has been found effective in reducing oocyst output from both
E. acervulina and E. tenella infections when fed at levels of 8.5
and 17 ppm in starter diets [22]. The mode of action is thought to
involve oxidative stress. Extracts from 15 Asian herbs were tested
for anticoccidial activity against E. tenella and the test criteria
were survival rate, bloody diarrhoea symptoms, lesion scores,
oocyst output, and technical performance. Practical applications
of these findings, such as the use of the products in starter rations
or combinations of them with current anticoccidials or vaccines,
appear possible and need to be investigated [1]. Therefore
far, chemoprophylaxis and anticoccidial feed additives have
controlled the disease but the situation has been complicated by
the emergence of drug resistance [46] and their potentially toxic
effects on the animal health [47].
Furthermore, drug or antibiotic residues in poultry products may be potentially hazardous to consumers. Another approach for coccidiosis control is the vaccination of birds with live Eimeria oocysts, but, in cases of poor management, these vaccines can trigger severe reactions that may affect the performance of flocks, mainly in broilers because of their rearing period [48]. As a result of this drawback of live vaccines, attenuated vaccines [with reduced pathogenicity] have been developed, but these are expensive to produce.
Furthermore, drug or antibiotic residues in poultry products may be potentially hazardous to consumers. Another approach for coccidiosis control is the vaccination of birds with live Eimeria oocysts, but, in cases of poor management, these vaccines can trigger severe reactions that may affect the performance of flocks, mainly in broilers because of their rearing period [48]. As a result of this drawback of live vaccines, attenuated vaccines [with reduced pathogenicity] have been developed, but these are expensive to produce.
Botanicals and Coccidiosis
Cost effective alternative strategies are being tried for more
effective and safer control of avian coccidiosis [49]. The use
of botanicals has played a strong role in the control of avian
coccidiosis, as they are not only natural products but may
include new therapeutic molecules to which immunity has not
yet developed. The use of botanicals as anticoccidial reduces,
therefore, holds possible as an alternative in the control of
coccidiosis.
Aloe Species
Aloes are believed to have several medicinal properties
and are used to treat various ailments. There are more than
360 known Aloe species, but the most recommended type of
Aloe in controlling coccidiosis is Aloe excelsa [50] revealed that
the anticoccidial effects of A. excelsa were comparable with
sulphachlopyrazine sodium monohydrate in terms of improved
live weight gains and reduction in oocyst output in infected
broiler chickens. Other species of Aloe plant such as Aloe vera
have also been reported to have anticoccidial activities.
Aloe vera treatments show toxic effects on the intestinal tract by benefiting microflora and reducing bowel putrefaction as well as reducing inflammation [51]. An in vitro study was undertaken to determine the effect of three concentrations [15%, 30%, and 45%] of A. Vera and A. spicata on the inhibition of the sporulation of avian coccidia oocysts [52]. The two extracts showed a concentration-dependant anticoccidial effect; however, A. spicata inhibited sporulation to a greater extent than A. vera. In another study [37] dietary supplementation of A. Vera resulted in significantly lower gut lesion scores and reduced faecal oocyst shedding of E. maxima in broiler chickens. These authors [37] suggested that reduced faecal oocyst shedding, a protective role against Eimeria infection, in Aloe-based chicken diets could be associated more with cell-mediated responses than antibody responses.
Aloe vera treatments show toxic effects on the intestinal tract by benefiting microflora and reducing bowel putrefaction as well as reducing inflammation [51]. An in vitro study was undertaken to determine the effect of three concentrations [15%, 30%, and 45%] of A. Vera and A. spicata on the inhibition of the sporulation of avian coccidia oocysts [52]. The two extracts showed a concentration-dependant anticoccidial effect; however, A. spicata inhibited sporulation to a greater extent than A. vera. In another study [37] dietary supplementation of A. Vera resulted in significantly lower gut lesion scores and reduced faecal oocyst shedding of E. maxima in broiler chickens. These authors [37] suggested that reduced faecal oocyst shedding, a protective role against Eimeria infection, in Aloe-based chicken diets could be associated more with cell-mediated responses than antibody responses.
Artemisia Species
The most common species is Artemisia annua which has been
reported for its antiparasitic activities. A. annua is a common
type of wormwood botanical anticoccidials: Abbas et al. [2004]
and [53] conducted the first experimental trial to evaluate the
anticoccidial activity of A. annua extracts against E. tenella in
chickens. A. annua extracts showed the anticoccidial activity
in terms of improved weight gain, improved feed conversion
ratio and reduced lesion scores in infected chickens. Later, [23]
reported a significant anticoccidial effect of A. annua against E.
tenella, measured as reduced lesion scores, when fed to broiler
chickens for three weeks as dried leaves at a dietary concentration
of 5% [equivalent to 17 ppm pure artemisinin].
The pure form of artemisinin, fed for a period of 4 weeks at levels of 2, 8.5 and 17 ppm, significantly decreased oocyst output from single and dual species infection with E. tenella and E. acervulina. Moreover, artemisinin isolated from A. sieberi was also found to be effective against E. tenella and E. acervulina but not against E. maxima [54]. So far, a limited amount of work has been carried out to determine the anticoccidial effect of Artemisia spp. in layer chickens. [55] Studied the effect of feeding 20% dried pulverized A. annua leaves against E. tenella both in broiler and layer chickens. The anticoccidial effects of diets containing A. annua leaves were almost equal to the commercial anticoccidials both in broiler and layer chickens. The proposed mechanism of action of artemisinin involves cleavage of endoperoxide bridges by iron producing free radicals [hypervalent iron-oxo species, epoxides, aldehydes, and dicarbonyle compounds] which damage biological macromolecules causing oxidative stress in the cells of the parasite [56].
The pure form of artemisinin, fed for a period of 4 weeks at levels of 2, 8.5 and 17 ppm, significantly decreased oocyst output from single and dual species infection with E. tenella and E. acervulina. Moreover, artemisinin isolated from A. sieberi was also found to be effective against E. tenella and E. acervulina but not against E. maxima [54]. So far, a limited amount of work has been carried out to determine the anticoccidial effect of Artemisia spp. in layer chickens. [55] Studied the effect of feeding 20% dried pulverized A. annua leaves against E. tenella both in broiler and layer chickens. The anticoccidial effects of diets containing A. annua leaves were almost equal to the commercial anticoccidials both in broiler and layer chickens. The proposed mechanism of action of artemisinin involves cleavage of endoperoxide bridges by iron producing free radicals [hypervalent iron-oxo species, epoxides, aldehydes, and dicarbonyle compounds] which damage biological macromolecules causing oxidative stress in the cells of the parasite [56].
Azadirachta Indica [Neem] Plant
Azadirachta indica [neem] plant is commonly available in
Asian and African countries and is well known in the therapy of
a number of infectious diseases including coccidiosis. Neem fruit,
at a concentration of 150 g/50 kg feed, has been found to have
anticoccidial effects against E. tenella infection by reducing oocyst
excretion and mortality in broiler chickens [57]. In addition to the
anticoccidial effect of neem fruit, some reports have shown the
anticoccidial activity of an aqueous extract of neem leaves against
E. tenella alone [58] as well as in a mixed infection [Biu et al.,
2006], which was comparable to the commercial anticoccidials
amprolium and baycox.
The exact mechanism of action of neem against coccidian parasites is unknown, but a report by the National Research Council [1992] [59] suggested that aqueous neem leaf extract, when taken orally, produces an increase in red cells, white blood cells and lymphocyte counts thus enhancing the cellular immune response, increasing antibody production and so most pathogens can be removed before they cause the symptoms associated with disease. Further study is needed to determine the maximum safe levels of neem supplementation because the higher doses, due to its bitterness, may show adverse effects on feed intake which will change the performance parameters of birds.
The exact mechanism of action of neem against coccidian parasites is unknown, but a report by the National Research Council [1992] [59] suggested that aqueous neem leaf extract, when taken orally, produces an increase in red cells, white blood cells and lymphocyte counts thus enhancing the cellular immune response, increasing antibody production and so most pathogens can be removed before they cause the symptoms associated with disease. Further study is needed to determine the maximum safe levels of neem supplementation because the higher doses, due to its bitterness, may show adverse effects on feed intake which will change the performance parameters of birds.
Beta Vulgaris
The beneficial effects of incorporating sugar beet [Beta
vulgaris] solids in animal feeds on livestock growth and overall
performance have been known for a long time. One of the active
ingredients is betaine which protects cells against osmotic
stress by stabilizing cell membranes through the maintenance of
osmotic pressure in the cells.
Curcuma Longa
Curcuma longa L. [Zingiberaceae], commonly known as
turmeric, is a medicinal plant widely used and cultivated in the
tropical regions. In developing countries like Pakistan, poultry
farmers provide turmeric powder as a feed additive for the control
of coccidiosis in broilers [60]. The active compound of turmeric
is the phenolic compound curcumin, which has been shown to
have antioxidative, anti-inflammatory and immunomodulatory
properties [56]. In an experimental study, the anticoccidial
effect of dietary supplementation of 1% curcumin was observed
in chickens after infection of E. maxima and E. tenella species.
Improved weight gain, reduced lesion scores and oocyst counts
were shown only against E. maxima. A significant reduction of
plasma NO2¯ and NO3¯ was found only in E. maxima-infected
and curcumin-treated birds, and hence provides a possible
explanation for the difference in anticoccidial activity found
for both Eimeria species [56]. Later [60] reported that dietary
supplementation with 3% C. longa powder was effective against a
mild infection of E. tenella.
The proposed mechanism of action of C. longa [curcumin] involves the induction of oxidative stress against coccidia. Further researches are required to determine the possible anticoccidial activity of different concentrations of whole C. longa and its active ingredient curcumin against different Eimeria species in poultry
The proposed mechanism of action of C. longa [curcumin] involves the induction of oxidative stress against coccidia. Further researches are required to determine the possible anticoccidial activity of different concentrations of whole C. longa and its active ingredient curcumin against different Eimeria species in poultry
Echinacea Purpure
Echinacea and its different preparations contain a variety
of active substances such as flavonoids, polysaccharides,
glycoproteins, alkamides, cinnamic acids, essential oils and
phenolic compounds [61; 62] which are effective in treatment
of various ailments and are proven to be beneficial in promoting
immunity [Bauer, 1999]. This plant is known to have antiinflammatory,
antioxidant and immunomodulating properties
that may be linked to its anticoccidial effects [62]. In an
experimental trial [56…], ground root preparations of E. purpurea
[0.1% -0.5%] were offered to broilers for two weeks which
ameliorated weight gain reduction and birds had fewer coccidial
lesions after a mixed challenge infection with E. acervulina,
E. maxima, E. tenella and E. necatrix. The exact mechanism of
action is still unknown, but because of its antioxidant properties
Echinacea therapy may induce a state of oxidative stress against
Eimeria species.
Origanum Vulgare
The essential oils of Origanum vulgare are well known for
their antiprotozoal activity [63, 64] carried out a study to examine
the effect of dietary supplementation of O. oregano [O. vulgare]
essential oil on performance of broiler chickens experimentally
infected with E. tenella. It was concluded that O. oregano
essential oils, mainly carvacrol and thymol, had anticoccidial
effects against E. tenella. Some studies suggest that vaccination
against coccidiosis, in combination with O. oregano containing
compounds, may be an alternative control method for intestinal
health in chickens [Waldenstedt, 2000a]. In addition, some works
suggested the use of dried oregano leaves as a natural herbal
growth promoter for early maturing of birds [65]. The dietary
supplementation of O. oregano containing plants like O. vulgare,
thus, seems equally effective for maintaining the performance
and reducing pathogenic parameters in infected birds.
Saccharum Officinarum
Sugar cane [Saccharum officinarum] extract [SCE], a well
known natural immunostimulant, is reported to have protective
effects against E. tenella infection in chickens [66]. Some
studies [67] showed a significant increase in the number of
IgM- and IgG plaque-forming cell responses of peripheral blood
leukocytes [PBL], intestinal leukocytes, splenocytes, in addition
to significantly higher phagocytic activity of PBL and antibody
responses in chickens that had been orally administered with
either sugar cane extract [SCE] or the polyphenol-rich fraction
[PRF]. Most recently, [68] reported the immunotherapeutic
effects of sugar cane extract against mixed Eimeria species in
broiler chickens. The results of these researches suggested that
sugar cane extract has an immunostimulating effect in chickens
and their administration may augment protective immunity
against coccidiosis.
Triticum Aestivum
The supplementation of whole Triticum aestivum [wheat]
grains in broiler feeds is common practice in Europe [28] because
dietary fibre anti- oxidants may actually quench the soluble
radicals that are continuously formed in the intestinal tract [69].
Many reports [56] have noted the protective effects of whole
cereal grains against coccidiosis in broiler chickens measured as a
reduction of oocyst output. However,[32] and [34] demonstrated
the effects of whole wheat inclusion in broiler feeds with or
without access to grit, and observed no significant differences
in oocyst counts of mixed Eimeria species. They concluded that
the reduction in output of oocysts by supplementation with
whole cereals in the diet was not a result of the crushing of
oocysts by an active gizzard or the increase in the viscosity of
the digesta. Furthermore, they concluded that the whole wheat
supplementation provided no control of coccidiosis in broiler
chickens.
Yucca Schidigera
Plant extracts with high saponin content are a good source
of natural antimicrobial compounds. Yucca schidigera is a major
source of natural saponins that cause the inhibition of protozoan
development by interacting with the cholesterol present on
the parasite cell membrane, thus resulting in parasite death
[70]. Several studies have shown a beneficial and synergistic
effect between the coccidiosis vaccine and the Y. schidigera
extract in improving weight gains, feed conversion ratio and
maintaining the integrity of the intestinal villi in chickens [71].
These improvements in the performance parameters of birds
may be the result of the potential of saponins [extracted from
the Y. schidigera] to improve the absorption of nutrients by the
intestinal mucosal surface [72]. These saponins are steroidal
glycosides with strong surfactant activity, reducing the superficial
tension of fluids and allowing better absorption of nutrients by
the intestinal epithelium.
Treatment Programme for Coccidiosis Control
Shuttle or Dual Program
The use of one product in the starter and another in the
grower feed is called a shuttle program in the US and a dual
program in other countries. The shuttle program usually is
intended to manage coccidiosis control. Intensive use of the
polyether ionophore drugs for many years produced strains
of coccidia in the field that have reduced sensitivity to the
ionophores. It is a common practice to use another drug such
as nicarbazin or halofuginone in the starter or grower feed to
bolster the anticoccidial control and take some pressure off the
ionophore. The use of shuttle programs is thought to reduce
buildup of drug resistance. In 1988, approximately 80% of the US
producers used some type of shuttle program [73], in which two
compounds usually a synthetic agent[such as Incarbazin] and
Ionophore [such as Salinomycin] are employed successively in
single flock. During 1999 in the US, shuttles involving synthetic
drugs followed by Ionophores were employed by approximately
25% of broiler complexes [74].
Future Hazards of Anticoccidial Residues in
Broilers Meat Tissues to Man
Anticoccidial drugs play an important role in animal
production, especially in intensive broiler production. They are
used for disease prevention and therapy, as well as for their
growth-stimulating effect. These drugs add to the recovery
of animals from protozoal endoparasites, increase breeding
productivity and decrease economic losses caused by coccidiosis.
However, mass and long-term administration of these substances
has brought problems connected to the occurrence of unfavorable
residues in animal products for human consumption.
The residues of anticoccidial drugs represent a potential risk to human health. Proper administration of these substances will ensure minimal content in animal products that will minimize health risks. To protect the health of consumers against the entry of residues of anticoccidial drugs into the food chain, it is necessary to monitor drug residues in animals for food production and for valid veterinary hygienic legislation to pay appropriate attention to this group of drugs [75]. Some anticoccdial drugs such as ionophores are not used in human medicine due to their potent cardiovascular effects. Ensure that recommended withdrawal periods are observed, it has been suggested that residues of ionophores in food could cause adverse health effects in humans as a result of their cardiovascular toxicity. Since poultry litter is extensively applied to land as manure ionophores and their degradation products may readily enter the soil and water environment.
Some studies have been published regarding the environmental fate of ionophores and thus it is difficult to assess their potential impact. Biodegradation studies have indicated that monensin is degradable under aerobic conditions with or without manure and in manure piles within 33 days. Degradation in manure piles under anaerobic conditions was less extensive. It should be assumed that the microbiological activity of soil will be affected, at least initially following application of ionophore containing manure and this may affect nutrient release.
Direct effects on plants are not expected except that an inhibitory effect on apple pollen has been reported for monensin. Ionophores may cause irritation and allergic reaction in humans and protective clothing and dust masks should be used whenever there is a risk of exposure. Alarming human health hazards, the emergence of resistant strains of bacteria in birds and passage of these or other resistant factors via food chain from birds to human beings. Use of antibiotics at sub-therapeutic levels in broiler feeds may lead to the development of resistant strains of bacteria in the bird. While consuming the meat containing residues of antibiotics over protracted period may lead to emergence of resistant gut flora and pathogens in human beings such as E. Coli and Salmonella spp. Production of harmful effects from direct toxicity or from the allergic reactions [hypersensitivity reactions] in persons already sensitized to them.
Certain drugs and or their metabolites possess carcinogenic potential e.g.sulphamethazine residues containing meat preserved with sodium nitrate may develop a triazine complex that has a considerable carcinogenic potential. Prolonged ingestion of tetracycline present in the broiler meat has detrimental effects on teeth and bones in growing children. Some tetracyclines, most therapeutic antibiotics are relatively heat stable and resist both pasteurization and cooking process [76]. Adverse effects on the cartilage development in children may result if the broiler meat contains quinolone residues. Drug residues may destroy the useful micro flora of gastrointestinal tract, especially in children and hence lead to enteritis [diarrhoea, dysentery] like problems. Super infections that refer to as fresh invasion or re40 infection added to an already existing infection. Candidiasis caused by Candida albicans is a classical example of the unhealthy consequence of the use of antibiotics. Residues of chloramphenicol are known to cause bone marrow depression and problems like anaemia in consumers [76].
In addition, there are many safe veterinary drugs and none withdrawal period like, amprolium [77]. Factors that leading to the occurrence of antibiotics residues in animal products are; failure to observe drug withdrawal period, extended usage or excessive dosages of antibiotics, non-existence of restrictive legislation or their inadequate enforcement, poor records of treatment, failure to identify treated animals, lack of advice on withdrawal periods, off-label use of antibiotics, availability of antibiotics to lay persons as over the counter drugs in the developing countries, the addition of antibiotics as milk preservatives during hauling from the centre of production[villages] to the centers of consumption [cities or factories] and lack of consumer awareness about the magnitude and human health hazards associated with antibiotic residues in the food of animal origin [76].
The residues of anticoccidial drugs represent a potential risk to human health. Proper administration of these substances will ensure minimal content in animal products that will minimize health risks. To protect the health of consumers against the entry of residues of anticoccidial drugs into the food chain, it is necessary to monitor drug residues in animals for food production and for valid veterinary hygienic legislation to pay appropriate attention to this group of drugs [75]. Some anticoccdial drugs such as ionophores are not used in human medicine due to their potent cardiovascular effects. Ensure that recommended withdrawal periods are observed, it has been suggested that residues of ionophores in food could cause adverse health effects in humans as a result of their cardiovascular toxicity. Since poultry litter is extensively applied to land as manure ionophores and their degradation products may readily enter the soil and water environment.
Some studies have been published regarding the environmental fate of ionophores and thus it is difficult to assess their potential impact. Biodegradation studies have indicated that monensin is degradable under aerobic conditions with or without manure and in manure piles within 33 days. Degradation in manure piles under anaerobic conditions was less extensive. It should be assumed that the microbiological activity of soil will be affected, at least initially following application of ionophore containing manure and this may affect nutrient release.
Direct effects on plants are not expected except that an inhibitory effect on apple pollen has been reported for monensin. Ionophores may cause irritation and allergic reaction in humans and protective clothing and dust masks should be used whenever there is a risk of exposure. Alarming human health hazards, the emergence of resistant strains of bacteria in birds and passage of these or other resistant factors via food chain from birds to human beings. Use of antibiotics at sub-therapeutic levels in broiler feeds may lead to the development of resistant strains of bacteria in the bird. While consuming the meat containing residues of antibiotics over protracted period may lead to emergence of resistant gut flora and pathogens in human beings such as E. Coli and Salmonella spp. Production of harmful effects from direct toxicity or from the allergic reactions [hypersensitivity reactions] in persons already sensitized to them.
Certain drugs and or their metabolites possess carcinogenic potential e.g.sulphamethazine residues containing meat preserved with sodium nitrate may develop a triazine complex that has a considerable carcinogenic potential. Prolonged ingestion of tetracycline present in the broiler meat has detrimental effects on teeth and bones in growing children. Some tetracyclines, most therapeutic antibiotics are relatively heat stable and resist both pasteurization and cooking process [76]. Adverse effects on the cartilage development in children may result if the broiler meat contains quinolone residues. Drug residues may destroy the useful micro flora of gastrointestinal tract, especially in children and hence lead to enteritis [diarrhoea, dysentery] like problems. Super infections that refer to as fresh invasion or re40 infection added to an already existing infection. Candidiasis caused by Candida albicans is a classical example of the unhealthy consequence of the use of antibiotics. Residues of chloramphenicol are known to cause bone marrow depression and problems like anaemia in consumers [76].
In addition, there are many safe veterinary drugs and none withdrawal period like, amprolium [77]. Factors that leading to the occurrence of antibiotics residues in animal products are; failure to observe drug withdrawal period, extended usage or excessive dosages of antibiotics, non-existence of restrictive legislation or their inadequate enforcement, poor records of treatment, failure to identify treated animals, lack of advice on withdrawal periods, off-label use of antibiotics, availability of antibiotics to lay persons as over the counter drugs in the developing countries, the addition of antibiotics as milk preservatives during hauling from the centre of production[villages] to the centers of consumption [cities or factories] and lack of consumer awareness about the magnitude and human health hazards associated with antibiotic residues in the food of animal origin [76].
Anticoccidial Testing in Birds
Three types of tests are generally used to study anticoccidial
drugs in broiler birds. These are; Battery tests: Done 7–14 days,
tests with birds in wire cages, Standard grow-out test: Done 6–8
weeks tests on birds in floor pens and Full-scale tests which is
done in commercial facilities. Each type has a different objective
and value to the investigator for example; the battery test is used
most effectively to measure the efficacy of an anticoccidial drug
against a variety of field isolates of Coccidia. This is an efficient and
relatively inexpensive testing procedure. The floor- pen test is an
intermediate testing procedure with a primary goal of providing
statistically useful performance data under controlled conditions.
Individually, the predictive value of each test is limited. One
cannot, for example, confidently extrapolate performance data in
a seven-day battery test to market weight, nor can one predict
from a few commercial trials the efficacy of an anticoccidial agent
in preventing the lesions of major species of Coccidia. As a whole,
when properly conducted, the tests complement one another
by providing a comprehensive picture of the efficacy, safety and
economic value of an anticoccidial agen.
Conclusion
Treatment and control of the disease are beset with several
problems prominent of which is the poor understanding of the
immune response. Another factor is the increasing incidence
of drug resistance in field strains of Eimeria. Furthermore, due
to health awareness there is increasing concern regarding
drug residues in poultry products and growing pressure from
Government and consumer on the production of drug-free
poultry products [78].
ReferencesTop
- Allen PC, Fetterer RH. Recent advances in biology and immunobiology of Eimeria species and in diagnosis and control of infection with these coccidian parasites of poultry. Clin Microbiol Rev. 2002; 15(1):58-65.
- Shirley MW1, Smith AL, Tomley FM. The biology of avian Eimeria with emphasis an emphasis on their control by vaccination. Adv Parasitol. 2005; 60:285-330. DOI:10.1016/S0065-308X(05)60005-X
- Leu S. Planning your attack against coccidiosis. Poultry Worid.1999;15: 111-113.
- Chapman HD, Cherry TE, Danforth HD, Richards G, Shirley MW, Williams RB. Sustainable coccidiosis control in poultry production: The role of live vaccines. Int J Parasitol. 2002; 32(5):617-29.
- Brussels. The rules governing medical products in the European Community IV, Commission of the European Community. 1991
- Fang GZ , He JX , Wang S. Multiwalled carbon nanotubes as sorbent for on-line coupling of solid-phase extraction to high-performance liquid chromatography for simultaneous determination of 10 sulfonamides in eggs and pork. Journal of Chromatography. A. 2006; 1127(1-2):12-17. DOI: 10.1016/j.chroma.2006.06.024.
- Zheng MM , Zhang MY , Peng GY , Feng YQ. Monitoring of sulfonamide antibacterial residues in milk and egg by polymer monolith microextraction coupled to hydrophilic interaction chromatography/mass spectrometry. Analytica Chimica Acta. 2008; 625(2):160-172. DOI: 10.1016/j.aca.2008.07.033.
- Khan MA, Younas M, Khan I, Abbas RZ, Ali M. Comparative efficacy of some herbal and homeopathic preparations against coccidiosis in broilers. International Journal of Agriculture and Biology. 2008; 10(3):358-360.
- Chapman, H. D. Biochemical, genetic and applied aspects of drug resistance in Eimeria parasite of the fowl. Avian Pathol. 1997; 26(2):221-244. DOI:10.1080/03079459708419208.
- Chapman, H. D. Anticoccidial Drug Resistance. The Biology of the Coccidia. P. L. Long, ed. University Park Press: Baltimore. 1982.
- McDougald LR. Coccidiosis. in Poultry Diseases. 2003.
- Jeurissen S H M, Veldman B. The interaction between feed (components) and Eimeria infection in poultry health. in Nutrition and Health of the Gastrointestinal Tract. M. C. Blok, H.A. Vahl, L. de Braak, G. Hemke, and M. Hessing, eds. Wageningen Academic Publisher, Wageningen, The Netherlands. 2002.
- Hussain Abo Alqomsan. Prevalence of caecal coccidiosis among broilers in Gaza strip. A Thesis submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirement for the Degree of Master of Biological Sciences.2010.
- Gabriel I, Mallet S, Leconte M. Effect of whole wheat feeding on the development of coccidial infection in broiler chickens until marketage. Animal Feed Science and Technology. 2006; 129: 179-303. DOI: 10.1016/j.anifeedsci.2006.01.004
- Aharon Friedman, David Sklan. Impaired T lymphocytes immune response in vitamin A depleted rats and chickens. British Journal of Nutrition. 1989; 62(2): 39-449. DOI:10.1079/BJN19890044